Reported Yes/No Questions with 'If/Whether'
Report yes/no questions by using `if` or `whether` as connectors and switching to statement word order with backshifted tenses.
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Replace question helpers like `do/did` with normal statement word order.
- Use `if` for casual reporting and `whether` for formal or complex choices.
- Shift tenses back one step if the reporting verb is in the past.
- Remove question marks because the sentence is now a declarative statement.
Quick Reference
| Direct Question | Connector | Reported Statement | Logic Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| "Are you happy?" | if | He asked if I was happy. | Verb 'to be' shifts back. |
| "Do you work here?" | whether | She inquired whether I worked there. | Drop 'do', use Past Simple. |
| "Can they help?" | if | I wondered if they could help. | Modal 'can' becomes 'could'. |
| "Did you see it?" | whether | He asked whether I had seen it. | Past Simple becomes Past Perfect. |
| "Will it work?" | if | They asked if it would work. | Future 'will' becomes 'would'. |
| "Have you eaten?" | whether | She asked whether I had eaten. | Present Perfect becomes Past Perfect. |
主な例文
3 / 8The manager asked `if` I was available for a quick meeting tomorrow.
مدیر پرسید که آیا فردا برای یک جلسه کوتاه وقت دارم یا نه.
The committee inquired `whether` the project had been completed on schedule.
کمیته جویا شد که آیا پروژه طبق برنامه تکمیل شده بود یا خیر.
She wanted to know `whether` or not we were going to accept the offer.
او میخواست بداند که آیا قرار است پیشنهاد را بپذیریم یا نه.
The 'Or Not' Rule
If you use 'or not' immediately after the connector, you must use 'whether'. You can't say 'if or not'. It’s like wearing a tie with a hoodie—it just doesn't work.
Word Order Trap
Don't forget to swap! Once you add 'if', the question dies and a statement is born. Keep the subject before the verb to stay safe.
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Replace question helpers like `do/did` with normal statement word order.
- Use `if` for casual reporting and `whether` for formal or complex choices.
- Shift tenses back one step if the reporting verb is in the past.
- Remove question marks because the sentence is now a declarative statement.
Overview
You are in a job interview. The recruiter leans forward. She asks, "Do you have experience with Python?" You answer confidently. Later, you tell your friend about it. You say, "She asked if I had experience with Python." This is the magic of reporting yes/no questions. It turns a direct inquiry into a smooth statement. At the C1 level, you need more than just the basics. You want to sound natural and precise. We use if or whether to bridge the gap. These words act like a glue. They connect the reporting verb to the original question. It is like telling a story instead of playing a recording.
How This Grammar Works
Direct questions are like sudden bursts of information. They use helping verbs like do, does, or did. When we report them, those helpers disappear. The sentence stops being a question. It transforms into a standard statement. Think of it as a grammar makeover. We shift the word order back to normal. We also move the tense backward in time. This is called backshifting. If the original question was in the present, the report is in the past. It might feel like a lot of moving parts. Do not worry. Your brain already does this in your native language. We just need to tune the English frequency.
Formation Pattern
- 1Creating these sentences follows a clear sequence.
- 2Start with a reporting verb.
Askedis the classic choice. You can also usewonderedorwanted to know. - 3Add your connector. Choose
iffor casual chats. Choosewhetherfor formal settings or reports. - 4Change the word order. Move the subject before the verb.
- 5Drop the auxiliary verbs. Say goodbye to
do,does, anddid. - 6Shift the tense. Change
istowasorhavetohad. - 7Update the pronouns. Make sure "you" becomes "I" or "he/she" correctly.
- 8Imagine you are at a cafe. A waiter asks, "Is this seat taken?" You tell your partner, "He asked
ifthat seat was taken." Simple, right?
When To Use It
Use this pattern whenever you recount a conversation. It is perfect for professional debriefs. Imagine explaining a client meeting to your boss. You would report their concerns using whether. It also works for social storytelling. Tell your friends what your crush asked you. It adds a layer of sophistication to your speech. It shows you can handle complex sentence structures. Use it in academic writing to report research questions. It is also vital for diplomatic communication. It softens the directness of a question. This makes you sound more polite and professional.
When Not To Use It
Do not use if or whether for open questions. If the question starts with Who, What, or Where, stay away. Those questions use the question word as the connector. For example, "Where are you?" becomes "He asked where I was." No if allowed here. Also, avoid this pattern when the question is actually a request. If someone says, "Can you pass the salt?", do not say, "He asked if I could pass the salt." Use an infinitive instead: "He asked me to pass the salt." It sounds much more natural. Finally, do not use it for rhetorical questions. If a teacher asks, "Are you serious?", they aren't looking for a yes/no report.
Common Mistakes
Many learners keep the question word order. They say, "He asked if was I ready." This sounds a bit clunky. Remember, it is now a statement! Use "He asked if I was ready." Another trap is keeping the do or did. Avoid saying, "She asked if did I like the movie." Just say, "She asked if I liked the movie." Yes, even native speakers mess this up when they are tired. Think of it like a grammar traffic light. Green means go with statement order. Red means stop using question helpers. Also, be careful with the tense. If the reporting verb is in the past, the rest must follow. Do not leave the second half in the present.
Contrast With Similar Patterns
What is the difference between if and whether? In many cases, they are interchangeable. However, whether is the sophisticated older sibling. Use whether when there are two clear options. For example, "I don't know whether to stay or go." Whether also loves the phrase "or not." You can say "whether or not I am invited." If is more common in daily speech. It is quick and easy. However, whether is mandatory after prepositions. You say, "We talked about whether we should move." You cannot use if there. It would sound very strange to a native ear.
Quick FAQ
Q. Can I use that instead of if?
A. No, that is for reporting statements, not questions.
Q. Does the meaning change between if and whether?
A. Usually, no. Whether just sounds a bit more formal and precise.
Q. What if the question is in the future?
A. Change will to would. "Will it rain?" becomes "He asked if it would rain."
Q. Is it okay to use the present tense if the fact is still true?
A. Technically yes, but backshifting is safer for exams and formal writing.
Q. Why does this feel so hard?
A. Because you are thinking too much! Practice until it becomes a habit. Think of it like learning a new dance step. At first, you watch your feet. Soon, you just move to the music.
Reference Table
| Direct Question | Connector | Reported Statement | Logic Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| "Are you happy?" | if | He asked if I was happy. | Verb 'to be' shifts back. |
| "Do you work here?" | whether | She inquired whether I worked there. | Drop 'do', use Past Simple. |
| "Can they help?" | if | I wondered if they could help. | Modal 'can' becomes 'could'. |
| "Did you see it?" | whether | He asked whether I had seen it. | Past Simple becomes Past Perfect. |
| "Will it work?" | if | They asked if it would work. | Future 'will' becomes 'would'. |
| "Have you eaten?" | whether | She asked whether I had eaten. | Present Perfect becomes Past Perfect. |
The 'Or Not' Rule
If you use 'or not' immediately after the connector, you must use 'whether'. You can't say 'if or not'. It’s like wearing a tie with a hoodie—it just doesn't work.
Word Order Trap
Don't forget to swap! Once you add 'if', the question dies and a statement is born. Keep the subject before the verb to stay safe.
Softening Requests
Technically you can report a request with 'if', but using 'asked me to' is much smoother. It's the difference between a robot and a human.
Politeness in Business
In English-speaking offices, reporting questions with 'whether' shows you are detail-oriented and professional. It sounds much more objective.
例文
8The manager asked `if` I was available for a quick meeting tomorrow.
Focus: if
مدیر پرسید که آیا فردا برای یک جلسه کوتاه وقت دارم یا نه.
Standard backshift from 'Are you available?'.
The committee inquired `whether` the project had been completed on schedule.
Focus: whether
کمیته جویا شد که آیا پروژه طبق برنامه تکمیل شده بود یا خیر.
'Whether' adds a professional tone to the report.
She wanted to know `whether` or not we were going to accept the offer.
Focus: whether or not
او میخواست بداند که آیا قرار است پیشنهاد را بپذیریم یا نه.
'Whether or not' is a very common C1 construction.
The client asked `if` we might consider a discount for bulk orders.
Focus: might
مشتری پرسید که آیا ممکن است برای سفارشهای عمده تخفیفی در نظر بگیریم.
Reporting 'May we consider...?' using 'might'.
My roommate asked `if` I'd finished the milk again.
Focus: I'd
هماتاقیم پرسید که آیا دوباره شیر را تمام کردهام.
Contraction 'I'd' (I had) used for speed in casual speech.
✗ He asked me if was I hungry. → ✓ He asked `if` I was hungry.
Focus: I was
او از من پرسید که آیا گرسنه هستم.
Avoid using question word order in the reported section.
✗ She asked if did I see the keys. → ✓ She asked `if` I had seen the keys.
Focus: I had seen
او پرسید که آیا کلیدها را دیده بودم.
Remove 'did' and shift the verb to Past Perfect.
The HR rep asked `whether` I would still apply if the salary were lower.
Focus: whether
نماینده منابع انسانی پرسید که اگر حقوق کمتر بود، آیا باز هم درخواست میدادم.
A reported second conditional question.
自分をテスト
Convert the direct question to reported speech: "Did you receive the email?"
He asked me ___ I had received the email.
We use 'if' or 'whether' to report yes/no questions, never 'that' or the original auxiliary 'did'.
Choose the correct word order for this reported question.
She wondered whether ___ the new software yet.
Reported questions use statement word order (Subject + Verb) and backshifted tenses.
Select the best connector for a formal report involving a choice.
The board discussed ___ the merger should proceed.
'Whether' is preferred in formal discussions and after prepositions like 'about' (implied here).
🎉 スコア: /3
ビジュアル学習ツール
If vs. Whether
The Reporting Decision Tree
Is it a Yes/No question?
Is the context formal?
Use 'Whether' + Statement Order
Tense Backshift Cheat Sheet
Present → Past
- • am/is → was
- • do → did
- • have → had
Past → Past Perfect
- • did → had done
- • was → had been
Modals
- • will → would
- • can → could
よくある質問
22 問It is when you tell someone about a question that could be answered with 'yes' or 'no'. Instead of repeating the exact words, you use a connector like if or whether.
These words act as links between the reporting verb and the information. They signal that the following information was originally a question.
No, that is reserved for statements. If you say 'He asked that I was ready', it sounds like a command or a mistake.
Yes, you must use statement word order (Subject + Verb). You should say if I was instead of if was I.
No, these auxiliary verbs disappear in reported speech. For example, 'Do you like tea?' becomes 'He asked if I liked tea.'
You remove it. Since the sentence is now a statement about a question, it ends with a period.
In daily conversation, yes. If is much more frequent because it is shorter and less formal.
You must use whether after a preposition or when the phrase 'or not' immediately follows it. For example, 'I am thinking about whether to go.'
Not really, it just emphasizes that there are two possibilities. It makes your sentence feel more balanced and complete.
Yes, and this is a key C1 skill. You would say 'The discussion was about whether the law should change.'
If you use 'He asks', you don't need to backshift the tense. You can say 'He asks if I am ready.'
You can say 'He asked if he could help me.' Note how can shifts to could.
No, if is also used in conditionals. You have to look at the reporting verb to know which one it is.
Yes, but it's better to use two separate clauses. 'He asked if I was hungry and whether I wanted pizza.'
You can use wonder, inquire, want to know, or query. Each one adds a slightly different flavor.
Absolutely. 'I wondered if she would arrive on time' is a very common and natural sentence.
If someone asks 'Shall we go?', it's often better to report it as a suggestion: 'He suggested that we go.'
Yes, in casual speech people often forget to backshift. However, for exams or professional writing, use was.
Usually, shall becomes should. For example, 'Shall I open the window?' becomes 'He asked if he should open the window.'
Many languages use a similar 'whether' word, but the word order shift is very specific to English. Always watch your subject-verb order.
Watch interviews and try to summarize the questions to a friend. 'The reporter asked the actor if he enjoyed the filming process.'
Master the use of whether in formal writing. It immediately raises the level of your English and makes you sound more authoritative.
関連する文法
Reported Speech with Modal Verbs
Overview You have already mastered the basics of reported speech. You know how to turn "I am tired" into "He said he wa...
Reported Commands and Requests
Overview Ever felt like a middleman? Someone gives you an order. Now you must tell someone else. This is where reported...
Reported Questions with Question Words
Overview Ever felt like a detective reporting back to headquarters? That is the essence of reported questions. At the C...
コメント (0)
ログインしてコメント無料で言語学習を始めよう
無料で始める