C1 Reported Speech Advanced 5 دقيقة للقراءة

Reported Questions with Question Words

To report a question word inquiry, use statement word order and shift the tense into the past.

The Rule in 30 Seconds

  • Switch question word order to statement order (Subject + Verb).
  • Backshift the main verb tense into the past.
  • Remove auxiliary verbs like do, does, and did.
  • Keep the original question word to connect the clauses.

Quick Reference

Direct Question Reported Question Tense Shift Key Change
Where is he? He asked where he was. Pres. -> Past Verb moves to end
Why did you go? She asked why I had gone. Past -> Past Perf. Remove 'did'
What are you doing? He asked what I was doing. Pres. Cont. -> Past Cont. Subject-Verb flip
When can we start? They asked when they could start. Can -> Could Modal backshift
How do you feel? She asked how I felt. Pres. -> Past Remove 'do'
Who has seen it? He asked who had seen it. Pres. Perf. -> Past Perf. Keep 'who' as subject

أمثلة رئيسية

3 من 9
1

He asked where I lived.

Él preguntó dónde vivía yo.

2

She wondered why the train was late.

Ella se preguntó por qué el tren llegaba tarde.

3

They inquired how long the flight would take.

Preguntaron cuánto duraría el vuelo.

💡

The Intonation Rule

When reporting, your voice shouldn't go up at the end. It's a statement, so keep your tone flat or falling.

⚠️

The 'Do' Danger Zone

Do not let 'do', 'does', or 'did' sneak into your reported sentences. They are like uninvited guests at a party—kick them out!

The Rule in 30 Seconds

  • Switch question word order to statement order (Subject + Verb).
  • Backshift the main verb tense into the past.
  • Remove auxiliary verbs like do, does, and did.
  • Keep the original question word to connect the clauses.

Overview

Ever felt like a detective reporting back to headquarters? That is the essence of reported questions. At the C1 level, you aren't just repeating words. You are retelling a mystery with professional precision. Reported questions with question words focus on who, what, where, why, when, and how. This isn't just a grammar trick. It is a vital tool for storytelling and reporting. You use it to describe interviews, meetings, or juicy gossip. Think of it as a bridge between two conversations. One happened in the past. The other is happening right now. Yes, even native speakers mess this up sometimes. We often forget to flip the word order back. But you are here to master the nuances. Let's make your English sound sophisticated and polished. Think of this like a grammar traffic light. It guides the flow of information smoothly.

How This Grammar Works

Direct questions are like a flashlight. They point directly at the answer. Reported questions are more like a soft lamp. They provide context and background information. When you report a question, it stops being a question. It transforms into a statement about a question. This is the most important part to remember. Because it is now a statement, the grammar changes. We lose the question mark and the rising intonation. We also lose the auxiliary verbs do, does, and did. These are only for direct questions. In reported speech, they just get in the way. It is like removing training wheels from a bicycle. You are ready for the real deal now. You just need to keep the wh- word. That word acts as the anchor for the whole sentence.

Formation Pattern

  1. 1Start with a reporting verb like asked or wondered.
  2. 2Keep the original question word such as where or why.
  3. 3Switch the word order to Subject + Verb.
  4. 4Move the verb tense one step into the past.
  5. 5Change pronouns to match the new speaker's perspective.
  6. 6Update time and place words like now to then.
  7. 7Remove the auxiliary verbs do, does, or did entirely.
  8. 8End the sentence with a period, not a question mark.

When To Use It

Use this when summarizing a business meeting for your boss. It shows you understood the key points of the discussion. Use it during job interviews to clarify what was asked. "I was asked why I wanted to leave my role." Use it when recounting directions you received while traveling. It helps keep the story organized and easy to follow. Use it when writing formal reports or academic papers. It adds a layer of professional distance to your writing. Use it when being polite or indirect with someone. Sometimes a direct question feels too aggressive or blunt. Reporting a question can soften the tone of the conversation. It makes you sound like a diplomat, not a prosecutor.

When Not To Use It

Don't use it if you are quoting someone exactly. Use quotation marks for direct speech instead. "He asked, 'Where is my coffee?'" is perfectly fine. Don't use it if the question is still current. Sometimes we keep the present tense if the fact remains true. "She asked where the station is" works if it's still there. Don't use it in very casual, fast-paced text messages. Often, a direct quote is faster and clearer for friends. "He's like, 'Where are you?'" is common in casual speech. Don't use it if you are using an indirect question. "Can you tell me where the bank is?" is different. That is a polite request, not a report of the past.

Common Mistakes

The most common error is keeping the question order. People often say, "He asked where was the hotel." Wrong. It must be, "He asked where the hotel was." Do not forget the tense shift, also known as backshifting. "She asked why he is late" should be "was late." Avoid the "do" trap at all costs. Never say, "He asked what did I want." It should be, "He asked what I wanted." Removing the auxiliary verb is a common hurdle for learners. Another mistake is adding a question mark at the end. Remember, it is a statement now, so use a period. Don't use if or whether with wh- question words. Those are only for "Yes/No" questions, not these specific ones.

Contrast With Similar Patterns

Compare this with "Yes/No" reported questions using if. "He asked if I was hungry" has no question word. Our current pattern always uses words like how or when. Contrast it with indirect questions used for politeness. "I wonder where she is" is a current thought. "I wondered where she was" is a report of the past. They look similar but serve very different purposes in speech. Also, look at noun clauses starting with that. Those don't work for questions, only for reporting statements. You cannot say, "He asked that where I lived." That is a messy mix of two different grammar rules. Keep your question words and your statements separate and clean.

Quick FAQ

Q. Do I always have to use asked?

A. No, use wondered, wanted to know, or inquired.

Q. Can I use told for reporting questions?

A. No, told is for statements, never for questions.

Q. Does how count as a question word?

A. Yes, it works exactly like who or where.

Q. What happens to can in these sentences?

A. It usually shifts to could to match the past.

Q. Is backshifting mandatory in every single case?

A. Not if the situation is still true today.

Q. Can I report a question someone asked themselves?

A. Yes, use he wondered why he had done that.

Q. Do I keep the word please?

A. Usually, no. It disappears in the reported version.

Reference Table

Direct Question Reported Question Tense Shift Key Change
Where is he? He asked where he was. Pres. -> Past Verb moves to end
Why did you go? She asked why I had gone. Past -> Past Perf. Remove 'did'
What are you doing? He asked what I was doing. Pres. Cont. -> Past Cont. Subject-Verb flip
When can we start? They asked when they could start. Can -> Could Modal backshift
How do you feel? She asked how I felt. Pres. -> Past Remove 'do'
Who has seen it? He asked who had seen it. Pres. Perf. -> Past Perf. Keep 'who' as subject
💡

The Intonation Rule

When reporting, your voice shouldn't go up at the end. It's a statement, so keep your tone flat or falling.

⚠️

The 'Do' Danger Zone

Do not let 'do', 'does', or 'did' sneak into your reported sentences. They are like uninvited guests at a party—kick them out!

🎯

Think of it as Noun Clauses

If you struggle with the order, remember it's the same as 'I know where he is'. The reported part acts like a noun.

💬

Polite Softening

In British English, reporting a question can be a very polite way to double-check information without sounding pushy.

أمثلة

9
#1 Basic

He asked where I lived.

Focus: where I lived

Él preguntó dónde vivía yo.

Standard backshift from 'Where do you live?'.

#2 Basic

She wondered why the train was late.

Focus: was late

Ella se preguntó por qué el tren llegaba tarde.

Statement word order used after 'why'.

#3 Edge Case

They inquired how long the flight would take.

Focus: would take

Preguntaron cuánto duraría el vuelo.

'Will' changes to 'would' in the report.

#4 Edge Case

He wanted to know who had left the door open.

Focus: who had left

Quería saber quién había dejado la puerta abierta.

'Who' acts as the subject here, so order stays similar.

#5 Formal

The interviewer asked what my greatest weakness was.

Focus: weakness was

El entrevistador preguntó cuál era mi mayor debilidad.

Classic professional use of reported speech.

#6 Correction

✗ He asked where was the station. → ✓ He asked where the station was.

Focus: station was

Él preguntó dónde estaba la estación.

Avoid putting the verb before the subject.

#7 Correction

✗ She asked why did I cry. → ✓ She asked why I cried.

Focus: why I cried

Ella preguntó por qué lloré.

The auxiliary 'did' must be removed.

#8 Advanced

She asked what on earth I thought I was doing.

Focus: what on earth

Preguntó qué demonios pensaba que estaba haciendo.

Includes an emphatic phrase 'on earth'.

#9 Advanced

He questioned how the situation had deteriorated so rapidly.

Focus: had deteriorated

Cuestionó cómo la situación se había deteriorado tan rápido.

Uses 'questioned' as a strong reporting verb.

اختبر نفسك

Change the direct question to reported speech: 'Where does she work?'

He asked ___.

✓ صحيح! ✗ ليس تمامًا. الإجابة الصحيحة: where she worked

We backshift the present tense 'works' to past 'worked' and remove 'does'.

Correct the word order: 'Why are you leaving?'

She wanted to know why ___.

✓ صحيح! ✗ ليس تمامًا. الإجابة الصحيحة: I was leaving

In reported questions, we use statement order: Subject (I) + Verb (was leaving).

Report this past tense question: 'What did you see?'

They asked me ___.

✓ صحيح! ✗ ليس تمامًا. الإجابة الصحيحة: what I had seen

Past simple 'did you see' backshifts to past perfect 'had seen'.

🎉 النتيجة: /3

وسائل تعلم بصرية

Direct vs. Reported Order

Direct (Question Order)
Where is the key? Where is the key?
Why do you stay? Why do you stay?
Reported (Statement Order)
...where the key was. ...where the key was.
...why I stayed. ...why I stayed.

Transformation Steps

1

Is there a Wh- word?

YES ↓
NO
Use if/whether.
2

Is there a 'do/does/did'?

YES ↓
NO
Shift tense and move verb.
3

Delete it and shift tense.

YES ↓
NO
Process complete.

Tense Shift Cheat Sheet

Present to Past

  • is -> was
  • works -> worked
📜

Past to Past Perfect

  • went -> had gone
  • did -> had done

الأسئلة الشائعة

20 أسئلة

We change it because the sentence is no longer an inquiry. It has become a statement about a question, so it needs statement grammar like he asked where I was.

No, you should never use both. If you have a question word like why, use only that: She asked why I left.

No, you don't need a comma in English reported speech. Just link the reporting verb and the question word directly like He asked where....

It becomes He asked who I was. Notice how who remains at the start but the verb was moves after the subject I.

Yes, how follows the same rules as who, what, and where. For example, He asked how I had fixed it.

If you use He asks, you don't need to backshift the tense. You would say He asks where you live.

No, asked does not take the preposition to. Just say He asked me where I was.

No, wondered usually stands alone. You can't say He wondered me; instead, say He wondered why I was late.

They usually shift to that and there. For example, He asked what that was instead of what is this.

Yes, remove it and change the main verb to the past perfect. Why did you go? becomes He asked why I had gone.

In cases like Who called?, the order stays the same. It becomes He asked who had called.

Yes, it is a great alternative to asked. It sounds very natural and professional in reports like Management wanted to know why....

Yes, the question word always introduces the reported clause. It acts like a conjunction in He asked why I was there.

If shall is used for a suggestion, it often shifts to should. Where shall we go? becomes He asked where they should go.

Yes, just use the past tense reporting verb. Even if it was years ago, you say He asked where I had been.

Because the sentence structure is now a declarative statement. You are telling someone a fact about a past inquiry.

It becomes He asked what time it was. Remember to put the subject it before the verb was.

It is always asked why. Never add for between the reporting verb and the question word.

You can in very informal speech, but it's better to use why for standard reporting. He asked why I left is much better.

In casual conversation, people might still understand you. But in a C1 exam or business setting, it will look like a mistake.

هل كان هذا مفيداً؟
لا توجد تعليقات بعد. كن أول من يشارك أفكاره!

ابدأ تعلم اللغات مجاناً

ابدأ التعلم مجاناً