Comma Before Subordinating Conjunction
In German, you must always use a comma to separate main clauses from subordinating clauses.
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Always place a comma before subordinating conjunctions like 'weil', 'dass', and 'wenn'.
- The comma separates the main clause from the dependent subordinate clause.
- Subordinating conjunctions always push the conjugated verb to the very end.
- Unlike English, this comma is mandatory and never optional in German writing.
Quick Reference
| Conjunction | Meaning | Word Order Effect | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| weil | because | Verb to end | Ich esse, weil ich Hunger habe. |
dass
|
that | Verb to end | Er sagt, dass er heute kommt. |
| wenn | if / when | Verb to end | Ich helfe dir, wenn ich Zeit habe. |
| obwohl | although | Verb to end | Sie lernt, obwohl sie müde ist. |
| ob | whether / if | Verb to end | Ich frage, ob er den Weg weiß. |
| damit | so that | Verb to end | Er spart, damit er ein Auto kauft. |
| da | since / because | Verb to end | Ich gehe, da es schon spät ist. |
Key Examples
3 of 8Ich trinke einen Kaffee, weil ich müde bin.
I am drinking a coffee because I am tired.
Ich hoffe, dass du einen schönen Tag hast.
I hope that you have a nice day.
Wenn es regnet, bleibe ich zu Hause.
If it rains, I stay at home.
The 'Breath' Rule is a Lie
Don't just put commas where you would pause for breath. In German, commas follow grammatical structures, not your lung capacity!
Watch the Verb!
Remember that the comma and the 'verb-at-the-end' rule are best friends. If you see one, you almost always need the other.
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Always place a comma before subordinating conjunctions like 'weil', 'dass', and 'wenn'.
- The comma separates the main clause from the dependent subordinate clause.
- Subordinating conjunctions always push the conjugated verb to the very end.
- Unlike English, this comma is mandatory and never optional in German writing.
Overview
German commas are not just for taking a breath. They are structural pillars that hold your sentences together. In English, we often treat commas as optional or stylistic choices. In German, they are mandatory rules. Think of the comma as a tiny traffic light. It tells the reader exactly where one idea ends and another begins. Specifically, when you use a subordinating conjunction, you are starting a dependent clause. This clause cannot stand on its own. It is like a sidekick to the main sentence. Because it is a separate structural unit, it needs a clear boundary. That boundary is the comma. If you forget it, the sentence looks like a messy pile of words to a native speaker. Yes, even native speakers mess this up sometimes! But for you, mastering this is a huge step toward sounding like a pro. It makes your writing clear and professional. Whether you are texting a friend or writing a cover letter, these commas matter.
How This Grammar Works
Subordinating conjunctions like weil, dass, and wenn create a "Nebensatz" or subordinate clause. This type of clause has a very specific personality. First, it depends on a main clause to make sense. Second, it has a weird habit of kicking the verb to the very end of the sentence. Because the word order changes so drastically, the comma acts as a warning sign. It says: "Hey! A new clause is starting, and the verb is going to be late!" The comma always sits right before the conjunction. It creates a clean break between the two parts of the sentence. This structure helps the brain process the information in chunks. Without the comma, the sentence would feel like a long, breathless run-on. In German, we love order and structure. The comma provides exactly that. It is the glue that connects your primary thought to your supporting details. Think of it as a logical divider in a filing cabinet.
Formation Pattern
- 1To build these sentences correctly, follow these simple steps:
- 2Write your main clause first. This part can usually stand alone.
- 3Place a comma immediately after the last word of the main clause.
- 4Write the subordinating conjunction (like
weilordass) right after the comma. - 5Write the rest of your information.
- 6Place the conjugated verb at the very end of the sentence.
- 7Example:
Ich lerne Deutsch(Main) +,+weil(Conjunction) +ich in Berlin arbeiten möchte(Rest + Verb). - 8Result:
Ich lerne Deutsch, weil ich in Berlin arbeiten möchte.
When To Use It
You must use a comma every single time you introduce a subordinate clause. This happens most often with these common conjunctions:
weil(because): Use this to give a reason. "Ich trinke Wasser, weil ich Durst habe."dass(that): Use this after verbs of speaking or thinking. "Ich glaube, dass es regnet."wenn(if/when): Use this for conditions or repeated events. "Ich bleibe zu Hause, wenn es schneit."obwohl(although): Use this for contrasts. "Ich gehe spazieren, obwohl es kalt ist."damit(so that): Use this for purpose. "Ich lerne, damit ich die Prüfung bestehe."
Whether you are ordering food ("Ich nehme den Salat, weil ich Vegetarier bin") or asking for directions ("Wissen Sie, ob der Bus hier hält?"), the rule remains the same. If there is a subordinating conjunction, there must be a comma before it.
When Not To Use It
You do not use this specific comma rule with coordinating conjunctions. These are the "ADUSO" words: aber, denn, und, sondern, oder. While aber and denn often take commas, und and oder usually do not when connecting short clauses or words.
Example: Ich esse Brot und ich trinke Milch. (No comma needed before und).
Also, do not put a comma if the conjunction is just part of a phrase and not starting a new clause. However, for A2 learners, the most important thing to remember is that weil, dass, and wenn are the "Comma Kings." They almost always demand a comma before them. Don't let und confuse you; it's a different animal entirely.
Common Mistakes
The most frequent mistake is simply forgetting the comma. English speakers do this constantly because our brains are trained to omit it.
- ✗
Ich weiß dass du kommst. - ✓
Ich weiß, dass du kommst.
Another mistake is putting the comma in the wrong place. It must go *before* the conjunction, not after it.
- ✗
Ich bleibe zu Hause weil, es regnet. - ✓
Ich bleibe zu Hause, weil es regnet.
Lastly, learners often forget the "Verb Kick." They put the comma but keep the verb in the second position.
- ✗
Ich lerne, weil ich bin müde. - ✓
Ich lerne, weil ich müde bin.
Remember: Comma first, then conjunction, then verb at the end. It's a three-step dance you need to memorize.
Contrast With Similar Patterns
It is helpful to compare subordinating conjunctions with coordinating ones. Coordinating conjunctions (und, oder) connect two equal parts. They don't change the word order. Subordinating conjunctions (weil, dass) create a hierarchy. One part is more important than the other.
In English, we say "I am happy because I am eating." No comma is required. In German, you say "Ich bin glücklich, weil ich esse." The comma is non-negotiable.
Also, watch out for denn vs. weil. Both mean "because." But denn is a coordinating conjunction. It takes a comma but does *not* move the verb to the end. weil takes a comma *and* moves the verb. It's like weil is the stricter, more demanding cousin of denn.
Quick FAQ
Q. Do I need a comma if the sentence is very short?
A. Yes, even for Ich weiß, dass er kommt.
Q. What if the weil clause comes first?
A. Then the comma stays between the two clauses. Weil ich Hunger habe, esse ich.
Q. Is it okay to skip the comma in WhatsApp messages?
A. Many people do, but it makes you look a bit messy. Better to keep it!
Q. Does ob (if/whether) also need a comma?
A. Yes, ob is a subordinating conjunction too.
Reference Table
| Conjunction | Meaning | Word Order Effect | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| weil | because | Verb to end | Ich esse, weil ich Hunger habe. |
dass
|
that | Verb to end | Er sagt, dass er heute kommt. |
| wenn | if / when | Verb to end | Ich helfe dir, wenn ich Zeit habe. |
| obwohl | although | Verb to end | Sie lernt, obwohl sie müde ist. |
| ob | whether / if | Verb to end | Ich frage, ob er den Weg weiß. |
| damit | so that | Verb to end | Er spart, damit er ein Auto kauft. |
| da | since / because | Verb to end | Ich gehe, da es schon spät ist. |
The 'Breath' Rule is a Lie
Don't just put commas where you would pause for breath. In German, commas follow grammatical structures, not your lung capacity!
Watch the Verb!
Remember that the comma and the 'verb-at-the-end' rule are best friends. If you see one, you almost always need the other.
Spot the Conjunction
When reading, use the comma as a signal to look ahead for the verb. It helps you understand long German sentences much faster.
Texting Habits
While native speakers might skip commas in quick WhatsApp messages, using them correctly makes you stand out as a high-level learner.
Exemples
8Ich trinke einen Kaffee, weil ich müde bin.
Focus: weil
I am drinking a coffee because I am tired.
The comma separates the reason from the action.
Ich hoffe, dass du einen schönen Tag hast.
Focus: dass
I hope that you have a nice day.
Commonly used after verbs like 'hoffen', 'glauben', or 'sagen'.
Wenn es regnet, bleibe ich zu Hause.
Focus: ,
If it rains, I stay at home.
The comma still separates the two clauses even when 'wenn' starts the sentence.
Können Sie mir sagen, ob der Zug pünktlich ist?
Focus: ob
Can you tell me if the train is on time?
Treat 'ob' just like 'weil' regarding commas.
Ich schicke Ihnen die Unterlagen, damit Sie sie unterschreiben können.
Focus: damit
I am sending you the documents so that you can sign them.
Essential for professional emails.
✗ Ich komme nicht weil ich krank bin. → ✓ Ich komme nicht, weil ich krank bin.
Focus: not, weil
I'm not coming because I'm sick.
Never skip the comma before 'weil'.
✗ Er sagt, dass er ist glücklich. → ✓ Er sagt, dass er glücklich ist.
Focus: ist
He says that he is happy.
The comma is there, but the verb must also move to the end.
Ich denke, dass er kommt, wenn er Zeit hat.
Focus: kommt, wenn
I think that he is coming if he has time.
Each new subordinating conjunction needs its own comma.
Test Yourself
Choose the correctly punctuated sentence.
___
You need a comma exactly before the conjunction 'weil'.
Where does the comma go in this sentence: 'Sie sagt dass sie morgen kommt'?
Sie sagt ___ dass sie morgen kommt.
The conjunction 'dass' always requires a comma before it to separate the main clause from the subordinate clause.
Identify the correct word order and punctuation.
Wir gehen spazieren, ___
The comma is already there, so you need the conjunction followed by the verb at the end.
🎉 Score: /3
Visual Learning Aids
English vs. German Comma Logic
Should I use a comma?
Is the next word 'weil', 'dass', or 'wenn'?
Are you connecting a main clause to a subordinate clause?
Place a comma BEFORE the conjunction!
The 'Big Three' Conjunctions
The Reason
- • weil
- • da
The Fact
- • dass
- • ob
The Condition
- • wenn
- • falls
Frequently Asked Questions
22 questionsIt is a word like weil or dass that connects a dependent clause to a main clause. These clauses cannot stand alone and require the verb to move to the end.
It provides a visual structure that helps readers identify where one clause ends and another begins. Without it, the sentence logic becomes difficult to follow.
Yes, even in a three-word clause like Ich weiß, dass..., the comma is mandatory. German rules don't care about sentence length.
It is better not to. While some people are lazy, correct punctuation is a sign of good education in German-speaking countries.
The conjugated verb is 'kicked' to the very end of the clause. For example: ...weil ich Hunger habe.
Yes, weil is extremely common, along with dass and wenn. You will use these in almost every conversation.
Think of dass as a bridge. You need a comma to step onto the bridge. It usually follows verbs like sagen or glauben.
Whenever wenn means 'if' or 'whenever', it starts a subordinate clause and needs a comma before it.
Yes, when als is used for a single event in the past (like 'when I was a child'), it requires a comma: Als ich klein war, ...
The comma still separates the two clauses. Example: Weil ich müde bin, schlafe ich. Note that the main clause verb then comes right after the comma.
Usually no. und is a coordinating conjunction, which follows different rules and typically doesn't need a comma between short clauses.
No, just like und, oder usually connects parts of a sentence without requiring a comma.
Yes, aber (but) almost always takes a comma before it, even though it is not a subordinating conjunction.
Sometimes in fast typing, but in any formal or semi-formal writing, they are very strict about it. It is much more noticeable than in English.
No, the Oxford comma is for lists. This German rule is for connecting entire ideas (clauses).
It's a way to remember that the conjunction and the verb 'sandwich' the rest of the clause: weil [ich heute keine Zeit] habe.
Semicolons are very rare in German. Stick to commas for subordinating clauses; a semicolon would look very strange there.
Yes, ob (whether/if) is a subordinating conjunction. Example: Ich weiß nicht, ob er kommt.
When you see a comma followed by a conjunction, your brain knows to wait until the very end of the sentence to find the action (the verb).
You need a comma for each one! Example: Ich glaube, dass er kommt, weil er Zeit hat.
Yes, from A1 to C2, the rule for commas before subordinating conjunctions never changes. It is a fundamental law of the language.
Memorize the 'Big Three': weil, dass, wenn. If you see them, 99% of the time, you need a comma right before them.
Grammaire lie
Subordinating Conjunction - weil
Overview Welcome to the world of German reasons! You probably want to explain why things happen. In English, we use the...
Coordinating Conjunction - und
Overview Welcome to your new favorite German word: `und`. It means "and." It is the simplest way to connect ideas. Thin...
Coordinating Conjunction - oder
Overview Life is a series of choices. Do you want coffee? Do you want tea? In German, the word `oder` is your best frie...
Subordinating Conjunction - dass
Overview `Subordinating Conjunction - dass` is a high-value German grammar point in the conjunctions area. This guide is...
Coordinating Conjunction - aber
Overview Do you want to express a contrast? Use the word `aber`. It translates directly to "but" in English. It is a co...
Commentaires (0)
Connectez-vous pour CommenterCommencez à apprendre les langues gratuitement
Commence Gratuitement