Modal Particle "schon" - Concession
Use `schon` to agree with a point politely before introducing a contrasting idea with `aber`.
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Use `schon` to acknowledge a fact before adding a 'but' with `aber`.
- It translates roughly to 'indeed' or 'it is true that' in this context.
- Place it immediately after the conjugated verb in your main clause.
- It makes your German sound more diplomatic, natural, and conversational.
Quick Reference
| Sentence Part 1 | The Particle | The Contrast | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Das Wetter ist... | schon schlecht, | aber wir gehen. | It's bad, but we're going. |
| Der Wein ist... | schon teuer, | aber er schmeckt. | It's expensive, but it's tasty. |
| Ich bin... | schon müde, | aber ich lerne. | I'm tired, but I'm studying. |
| Die Wohnung ist... | schon klein, | aber sie ist billig. | It's small, but it's cheap. |
| Deutsch ist... | schon schwer, | aber es macht Spaß. | It's hard, but it's fun. |
| Das Handy ist... | schon alt, | aber es funktioniert. | It's old, but it works. |
Key Examples
3 of 8Das ist schon richtig, aber nicht perfekt.
That is indeed correct, but not perfect.
Er ist schon nett, aber sehr ruhig.
He is indeed nice, but very quiet.
Hast du Hunger? - Ja, schon.
Are you hungry? - Yes, somewhat (but I can wait).
The 'Aber' Anchor
Always look for the 'aber'. If you see 'schon' and 'aber' in the same sentence, it's almost always this concession rule.
Pronunciation Matters
Don't say 'schön' (beautiful) when you mean 'schon'. One sounds like 'sh-urn' and the other like 'sh-own'. It changes the meaning entirely!
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Use `schon` to acknowledge a fact before adding a 'but' with `aber`.
- It translates roughly to 'indeed' or 'it is true that' in this context.
- Place it immediately after the conjugated verb in your main clause.
- It makes your German sound more diplomatic, natural, and conversational.
Overview
Welcome to the world of German modal particles! These are tiny words that add flavor to your sentences. Today, we are looking at schon. You might know it as "already." But in this lesson, it means something else. It acts like a bridge. It helps you agree with someone while preparing a "but." Think of it as a polite nod. You acknowledge a fact before you pivot. It is very common in daily German life. It makes you sound more natural and less like a robot. Even native speakers use it to soften their opinions. It is like a grammar traffic light. It turns yellow to say, "Wait, there is more!"
How This Grammar Works
In this context, schon is a concession particle. You use it to admit that a specific point is true. However, you usually follow it with a contradiction. It is the German way of saying "granted" or "it is true that." Imagine you are at a restaurant. Your friend says the soup is cold. You taste it and agree. You say, "It is cold, but it tastes good." In German, you use schon to give that first part more weight. It shows you are listening. It shows you are not just arguing for the sake of it. It creates a balance in your conversation. Without it, your sentences might sound too blunt or aggressive.
Formation Pattern
- 1Using
schonis quite simple. You do not need to change the word at all. It does not have endings. Follow these steps to build your sentence: - 2Start with your main subject and verb.
- 3Place
schonright after the conjugated verb. - 4Add the adjective or fact you are conceding.
- 5Put a comma to separate the thoughts.
- 6Use
aber(but) to introduce your counter-point. - 7Finish with your second thought.
- 8Example:
Das Auto ist schon alt, aber es fährt gut.(The car is indeed old, but it drives well.)
When To Use It
You use this version of schon in specific scenarios. Use it when you want to be diplomatic. Use it when someone makes a valid point you cannot deny.
- Ordering Food:
Die Pizza ist schon groß, aber ich habe Hunger.(The pizza is indeed big, but I am hungry.) - Job Interviews:
Ich habe schon wenig Erfahrung, aber ich lerne schnell.(I do have little experience, but I learn fast.) - Asking Directions:
Der Weg ist schon weit, aber wir gehen zu Fuß.(The way is indeed far, but we are walking.) - Weather Talk:
Es ist schon kalt, aber die Sonne scheint.(It is indeed cold, but the sun is shining.)
When Not To Use It
Do not use this schon if you are talking about time. If you say Ich bin schon da, it means "I am already here." That is a different rule! Also, do not use it if you completely disagree. If you think the pizza is small, do not use schon. Only use it when the first part of the sentence is a fact you accept. Avoid using it in very short, one-word answers unless the context is very clear. It needs a partner (usually aber) to make sense. If you use it alone, people might wait for you to finish your sentence. It is like leaving a high-five hanging!
Common Mistakes
The most common mistake is forgetting the aber. If you just say Das ist schon teuer, it sounds incomplete. The listener is waiting for the "but." Another mistake is the word order. Do not put schon at the very end of the sentence. It belongs near the verb. Some learners also confuse it with schön (beautiful). Watch that pronunciation! One little umlaut changes everything. You don't want to tell your boss his idea is "beautifully wrong" when you meant "granted, it's wrong." Yes, even native speakers might chuckle if you mix those up.
Contrast With Similar Patterns
You might wonder about zwar. Both schon and zwar work with aber. However, zwar is more formal. You will see zwar in newspapers or books. schon is the friendly, casual cousin. It is perfect for chatting with friends or colleagues. There is also doch. While doch is used to contradict a negative, schon is used to agree with a fact before adding a twist. Think of schon as the "Yes, but..." and doch as the "Actually, yes!" knowing the difference helps you navigate social nuances like a pro.
Quick FAQ
Q. Does schon always mean "already"?
A. No, as a particle, it shows concession or emphasis.
Q. Can I use it without aber?
A. Sometimes, if the "but" is implied by your tone, but it is rare for beginners.
Q. Is it formal?
A. It is neutral. You can use it with your boss or your best friend.
Q. Where does it go in the sentence?
A. Usually right after the verb in position two.
Reference Table
| Sentence Part 1 | The Particle | The Contrast | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Das Wetter ist... | schon schlecht, | aber wir gehen. | It's bad, but we're going. |
| Der Wein ist... | schon teuer, | aber er schmeckt. | It's expensive, but it's tasty. |
| Ich bin... | schon müde, | aber ich lerne. | I'm tired, but I'm studying. |
| Die Wohnung ist... | schon klein, | aber sie ist billig. | It's small, but it's cheap. |
| Deutsch ist... | schon schwer, | aber es macht Spaß. | It's hard, but it's fun. |
| Das Handy ist... | schon alt, | aber es funktioniert. | It's old, but it works. |
The 'Aber' Anchor
Always look for the 'aber'. If you see 'schon' and 'aber' in the same sentence, it's almost always this concession rule.
Pronunciation Matters
Don't say 'schön' (beautiful) when you mean 'schon'. One sounds like 'sh-urn' and the other like 'sh-own'. It changes the meaning entirely!
Sound Like a Local
Use 'Ja, schon' when someone asks your opinion on something you half-agree with. It makes you sound very authentic.
German Directness
Germans use 'schon' to be polite. It shows you acknowledge the other person's reality before you offer your own perspective.
Exemples
8Das ist schon richtig, aber nicht perfekt.
Focus: schon richtig
That is indeed correct, but not perfect.
A classic way to give feedback politely.
Er ist schon nett, aber sehr ruhig.
Focus: schon nett
He is indeed nice, but very quiet.
Describing someone's personality with balance.
Hast du Hunger? - Ja, schon.
Focus: Ja, schon
Are you hungry? - Yes, somewhat (but I can wait).
Here, the 'but' is hidden in the tone.
Ich komme schon!
Focus: komme schon
I'm coming (don't worry)!
This is more about reassurance than concession.
Ihr Vorschlag ist schon interessant, aber zu teuer.
Focus: schon interessant
Your proposal is indeed interesting, but too expensive.
Using 'schon' to soften a rejection in a meeting.
✗ Das ist schon teuer. ✓ Das ist schon teuer, aber die Qualität ist gut.
Focus: aber
That is indeed expensive, but the quality is good.
Without the 'aber', the sentence feels like it's missing a limb.
✗ Ich bin schon müde. (meaning 'already') → ✓ Ich bin schon müde, aber ich bleibe.
Focus: schon müde
I am indeed tired, but I am staying.
Context determines if 'schon' means 'already' or 'indeed'.
Es mag schon sein, dass er recht hat.
Focus: mag schon sein
It may well be that he is right.
A more complex structure using 'mag' for possibility.
Test Yourself
Complete the sentence to show concession.
Der Kaffee ist ___ heiß, aber er schmeckt sehr gut.
We use 'schon' to acknowledge the coffee is hot before the 'aber' clause.
Choose the best word to balance the sentence.
Das Hotel ist schon alt, ___ es ist sehr sauber.
'Schon' almost always pairs with 'aber' to show contrast.
Where does 'schon' go?
Ich ___ schon Zeit, aber ich will nicht.
'Schon' follows the conjugated verb 'habe' in this sentence.
🎉 Score: /3
Visual Learning Aids
Time vs. Concession
Should I use 'schon'?
Are you agreeing with a fact?
Is there a 'but' (aber) coming?
Is it after the verb?
Common Scenarios for Concession
Shopping
- • Schon teuer, aber schön.
- • Schon groß, aber passt.
Work
- • Schon viel Arbeit, aber okay.
- • Schon spät, aber ich bleibe.
Frequently Asked Questions
21 questionsIt means 'indeed' or 'it's true that'. It is used to concede a point before adding a contrast with aber.
No, in this context, it is a modal particle. It doesn't change based on gender or case.
Usually no. It typically follows the verb, like in Das ist schon wahr.
They are very similar! Zwar is more formal, while schon is common in spoken German.
Look for the aber. If there is a contrast, it means 'indeed'. If it's about time, it means 'already'.
Yes, but it's less common. An example is Ist das schon dein Ernst? (Are you actually serious?).
No, the verb stays in position two. schon just sits quietly after it.
Absolutely! It's one of the first 'flavor words' you should learn to sound more natural.
The sentence feels unfinished. Your listener might wait for you to keep talking.
Not really. schon needs a contrast, so aber is the perfect partner.
Yes, but zwar is often preferred in very formal essays. schon is great for emails and speech.
Yes, like Das ist schon nicht schlecht, aber... (It's indeed not bad, but...).
Yes, but it is most common with sein (to be) and haben (to have).
Yes! schon has a long 'o' like 'go'. schön has the 'ö' sound like 'bird'.
Yes, it's a common way to say 'Well, yeah, I guess so'.
Yes, it softens a contradiction. It shows you aren't just saying 'No'.
It is used everywhere! It is a standard part of the German language.
Yes, you can say Es ist schon teuer, aber ich kaufe es trotzdem (It's indeed expensive, but I'm buying it anyway).
No, modal particles never change their form.
Try making 'Yes, but' sentences about things in your room. Die Lampe ist schon alt, aber sie ist hell.
Because it changes the 'mode' or 'mood' of the sentence without changing the basic facts.
Grammaire lie
Konjunktiv I for Indirect Speech - Present Tense
Overview Welcome to the world of professional reporting! Imagine you are a news anchor. You need to tell your audience w...
Omission of "dass" in Indirect Speech
Overview German grammar can feel like a giant, complex puzzle. You have all these pieces and you try to fit them togethe...
Modal Verbs in Konjunktiv I
Overview Welcome to the world of the 'Reporter Voice.' In German, we call this `Konjunktiv I`. It sounds fancy, but it...
Konjunktiv I in Questions
Overview Welcome to the world of the "Messenger Mood." Konjunktiv I is a special way to use verbs in German. You use it...
Consecutive Konjunktiv I
Overview Welcome to one of the most elegant corners of the German language. You might be at the A1 level, but that does...
Commentaires (0)
Connectez-vous pour CommenterCommencez à apprendre les langues gratuitement
Commence Gratuitement