B1 Expression ニュートラル 3分で読める

هل لديك فكرة أفضل؟

Do you have a better idea?

直訳: At you an idea better?

Use this phrase to politely pivot away from a bad plan and invite collaborative suggestions.

15秒でわかる

  • A polite way to ask for a better suggestion or plan.
  • Works in both casual hangouts and professional brainstorming sessions.
  • Requires slight grammatical changes based on the gender of the listener.

意味

This phrase is used when you aren't quite satisfied with a current plan and want to see if someone else has a more creative or practical suggestion.

主な例文

3 / 6
1

Choosing a dinner spot

المطعم ده زحمة جداً، عندك فكرة أحسن؟

This restaurant is very crowded, do you have a better idea?

😊
2

In a creative meeting

التصميم ده مش عاجبني، عندك فكرة أحسن؟

I don't like this design, do you have a better idea?

💼
3

Texting a friend about a movie

الفيلم ده شكله ممل، عندك فكرة أحسن؟

This movie looks boring, do you have a better idea?

🤝
🌍

文化的背景

The phrase reflects the 'Shura' (consultation) tradition in Arab culture, where collective decision-making is valued over individual dictates. It has been a staple of daily conversation for decades, bridging the gap between formal and colloquial speech. In modern times, it's a common 'filler' in brainstorming sessions from Dubai to Casablanca.

💡

The Gender Switch

Remember that 'Andak' is for men and 'Andik' is for women. If you're texting and lazy, just write 'عندك'—the reader will know which one you mean based on who they are!

⚠️

Tone is Everything

In Arabic culture, saying this with a flat or rising friendly tone is an invitation. Saying it with a sharp, falling tone can sound like you're daring them to find a better way, which might cause an argument.

15秒でわかる

  • A polite way to ask for a better suggestion or plan.
  • Works in both casual hangouts and professional brainstorming sessions.
  • Requires slight grammatical changes based on the gender of the listener.

What It Means

Imagine you are standing on a street corner with friends. Everyone is hungry, but nobody wants pizza for the third time this week. You look at your best friend and say, عندك فكرة أحسن؟. You are basically saying, "I'm not feeling this plan, do you have something better?" It is a call for help and a way to pass the ball to someone else. It is direct but remains friendly because it shows you value their opinion.

How To Use It

You can use this phrase almost anywhere. It is like a Swiss Army knife for decision-making. In Arabic, the word عندك changes slightly depending on who you are talking to. If you are talking to a man, say Andak. For a woman, say Andik. For a group, say Andukum. It usually comes at the end of a conversation about a plan. It acts as a bridge to a new, better topic.

When To Use It

This phrase is perfect for those "meh" moments in life. Use it at a restaurant when the menu looks boring. Use it in a business meeting when the current strategy feels like a dead end. It is great for texting when you are trying to coordinate a hangout. It keeps the energy high and the conversation moving forward. It shows you are open-minded and ready for an adventure.

When NOT To Use It

Be careful with your tone. If you say it with a sneer, it sounds like a challenge. "Oh, you think you're so smart? Do you have a better idea?" Avoid using it with a superior who just gave a direct command. That might look like you are undermining their authority. Also, if a friend is very sensitive about a plan they worked hard on, maybe skip it. You don't want to accidentally crush their spirit over a dinner choice.

Cultural Background

In many Arabic-speaking cultures, group consensus is a big deal. There is a concept called *Shura*, which means consultation. People love to discuss and debate before making a final choice. This phrase fits perfectly into that cultural groove. It invites others into the circle of decision-making. It turns a solo choice into a shared experience. It is a very social way to navigate the world.

Common Variations

Depending on where you are, you might hear different versions. In the Levant (Lebanon, Syria, Jordan), you might hear عندك شي أحسن؟ (Do you have something better?). In Egypt, people might say عندك فكرة تانية؟ (Do you have another idea?). If you want to be more formal, you could say هل لديك اقتراح أفضل؟. But for daily life, the standard عندك فكرة أحسن؟ is your best bet.

使い方のコツ

The phrase is highly versatile and fits into the 'Neutral' register. The main 'gotcha' is the gender suffix: use 'ak' for males and 'ik' for females to sound natural.

💡

The Gender Switch

Remember that 'Andak' is for men and 'Andik' is for women. If you're texting and lazy, just write 'عندك'—the reader will know which one you mean based on who they are!

⚠️

Tone is Everything

In Arabic culture, saying this with a flat or rising friendly tone is an invitation. Saying it with a sharp, falling tone can sound like you're daring them to find a better way, which might cause an argument.

💬

The Power of 'Ahsan'

The word 'Ahsan' (better) comes from the root H-S-N, which is related to beauty and goodness. So you aren't just asking for a more 'efficient' idea, but a 'better/finer' one.

例文

6
#1 Choosing a dinner spot
😊

المطعم ده زحمة جداً، عندك فكرة أحسن؟

This restaurant is very crowded, do you have a better idea?

A classic way to pivot when a plan hits a physical obstacle.

#2 In a creative meeting
💼

التصميم ده مش عاجبني، عندك فكرة أحسن؟

I don't like this design, do you have a better idea?

Direct feedback followed by an invitation for input.

#3 Texting a friend about a movie
🤝

الفيلم ده شكله ممل، عندك فكرة أحسن؟

This movie looks boring, do you have a better idea?

Informal and collaborative for weekend planning.

#4 When a friend suggests a weird plan
😄

نمشي كل المسافة دي؟ عندك فكرة أحسن؟

Walk all that distance? Do you have a better idea?

Slightly skeptical but still open to suggestions.

#5 Trying to solve a recurring problem
💭

كل مرة بنتأخر، عندك فكرة أحسن؟

We are late every time, do you have a better idea?

Used to address a pattern of failure with a partner or friend.

#6 Discussing travel routes
😊

الطريق ده طويل، عندك فكرة أحسن؟

This road is long, do you have a better idea?

Practical use during a trip or commute.

自分をテスト

Choose the correct form of 'you have' for a female friend.

يا سارة، ___ فكرة أحسن؟

✓ 正解! ✗ おしい! 正解: عندكِ

In Arabic, 'Andik' (written as عندكِ or simply عندك with a kasra) is the feminine singular form.

Complete the sentence to ask for a better idea.

أنا مش عارف، عندك ___ أحسن؟

✓ 正解! ✗ おしい! 正解: فكرة

'Fikra' means 'idea', which completes the common expression.

🎉 スコア: /2

ビジュアル学習ツール

Formality Spectrum

Very Informal

Used with siblings or very close friends.

عندك شي أحسن؟

Neutral

Standard daily use with colleagues or friends.

عندك فكرة أحسن؟

Formal

Used in official meetings or with strangers.

هل لديك اقتراح أفضل؟

Where to use 'عندك فكرة أحسن؟'

عندك فكرة أحسن؟

At a Cafe

When the coffee is bad.

💼

Office Meeting

When a project is stuck.

🏠

With Family

Deciding on a holiday destination.

📱

Texting

Planning a Friday night out.

よくある質問

10 問

Not at all, as long as your tone is helpful. It's a standard way to collaborate in Arabic. For example, عندك فكرة أحسن؟ is very common among friends.

Yes, but use a softer tone. It shows you are thinking critically about the work. You might add يا فندم (sir) in some dialects to keep it respectful.

The feminine version is عندكِ فكرة أحسن؟ (Andik fikra ahsan?). The spelling is the same in most casual writing, but the pronunciation changes.

You would say عندي فكرة أحسن (Andi fikra ahsan). Simply change the 'k' to an 'i' at the end of 'Andak'.

Yes, it is understood everywhere. While some regions have local variations like عندك شي تاني؟, the core phrase is universal.

It means 'idea' or 'thought'. It comes from the verb فكر (fakkara), which means 'to think'.

Yes, you can swap 'fikra' for other nouns. For example, عندك حل أحسن؟ (Do you have a better solution?).

You can also use أفضل (afdal), which is slightly more formal. عندك فكرة أفضل؟ sounds a bit more professional.

A common response is ممكن... (Maybe...) followed by a suggestion, or لأ، فكرتك كويسة (No, your idea is good).

Absolutely! It's very common in WhatsApp chats when groups are trying to coordinate plans.

関連フレーズ

شو رأيك؟ (What do you think?)

في حل تاني؟ (Is there another solution?)

اقترح عليّ (Suggest something to me)

خلينا نشوف (Let's see/Let's check)

役に立った?
まだコメントがありません。最初に考えをシェアしましょう!

無料で言語学習を始めよう

無料で始める