Peer review comments were
Research methodology and reporting expression
Use this to professionally introduce expert critiques when discussing project improvements or publication status.
15秒でわかる
- Introduces expert feedback on a professional or academic project.
- Used to summarize critiques before making final edits or changes.
- Signals a high level of professional rigor and quality control.
意味
This phrase introduces the specific feedback, critiques, or suggestions given by experts who reviewed a piece of academic or professional work before its publication.
主な例文
3 / 6Updating a research team
The peer review comments were surprisingly positive regarding our data set.
The peer review comments were surprisingly positive regarding our data set.
Discussing a rejected paper
The peer review comments were brutal, but they pointed out a major flaw.
The peer review comments were brutal, but they pointed out a major flaw.
A formal email to a supervisor
Peer review comments were received this morning and require significant revisions.
Peer review comments were received this morning and require significant revisions.
文化的背景
The peer review system dates back to the 18th century but became the standard for science in the mid-20th century. It represents the cultural value of 'meritocracy' and objective truth in Western institutions. In modern times, the frustration over 'Reviewer 2' has become a shared bonding experience for academics worldwide.
Pair with Adjectives
Always follow this phrase with a strong adjective like `insightful`, `stringent`, or `valid` to sound more like a native expert.
Don't say 'The' every time
In formal reports, you can drop 'The' at the start (e.g., 'Peer review comments were...') to sound more concise and clinical.
15秒でわかる
- Introduces expert feedback on a professional or academic project.
- Used to summarize critiques before making final edits or changes.
- Signals a high level of professional rigor and quality control.
What It Means
Peer review comments were is the starting point for sharing feedback from experts. In the academic and professional world, people check each other's work. This process is called peer review. When you use this phrase, you are about to list the specific points they liked or hated. It is the 'moment of truth' for any researcher or writer. It bridges the gap between your hard work and the final polished version.
How To Use It
You use this phrase to summarize the results of an evaluation. Usually, you follow it with an adjective or a detailed list. For example, you might say they were constructive or brutal. It acts as a header for a discussion. You can use it in meetings or emails to update your team. It helps you stay objective about criticism. It makes the feedback feel less like a personal attack and more like a professional step.
When To Use It
Use this in any setting involving formal quality control. This includes university settings, scientific research, or high-level corporate reporting. If you just received an email from a journal editor, this is your go-to line. It is perfect for a 'lessons learned' meeting after a project. Use it when you need to justify why you are changing parts of your work. It shows you are listening to the experts.
When NOT To Use It
Do not use this for casual feedback from friends. If your buddy tells you your outfit looks weird, those aren't peer review comments. Avoid it in low-stakes situations like choosing a movie. It sounds too robotic for a coffee date or a family dinner. Also, do not use it if the review wasn't done by 'peers' (people of equal professional standing). If your boss just yells at you, that is 'feedback,' not a peer review.
Cultural Background
In Western academia, the peer review process is the 'gold standard.' It is often 'double-blind,' meaning you don't know who reviewed you. This creates a culture of honest, sometimes harsh, critique. There is a famous internet meme about 'Reviewer 2,' who is always the meanest. Using this phrase acknowledges that you have survived this stressful cultural ritual. It is a badge of honor in the scientific community.
Common Variations
You might hear The reviewers noted that or Feedback from the panel suggested. Some people say The peer review was favorable to summarize the whole vibe. If the news was bad, you might hear The comments were extensive. If they were helpful, you say they were insightful. These variations help you control the 'temperature' of the conversation.
使い方のコツ
This is a high-level academic and professional expression. It is almost exclusively used in formal writing or professional discussions regarding quality control and validation of work.
Pair with Adjectives
Always follow this phrase with a strong adjective like `insightful`, `stringent`, or `valid` to sound more like a native expert.
Don't say 'The' every time
In formal reports, you can drop 'The' at the start (e.g., 'Peer review comments were...') to sound more concise and clinical.
The 'Reviewer 2' Joke
If you want to bond with English-speaking academics, mention that 'Reviewer 2's comments were tough.' It's a universal joke about the one person who always hates the paper.
例文
6The peer review comments were surprisingly positive regarding our data set.
The peer review comments were surprisingly positive regarding our data set.
Used to share good news with colleagues.
The peer review comments were brutal, but they pointed out a major flaw.
The peer review comments were brutal, but they pointed out a major flaw.
Honest reflection on tough feedback.
Peer review comments were received this morning and require significant revisions.
Peer review comments were received this morning and require significant revisions.
Formal status update.
The peer review comments were basically a list of reasons why I should quit.
The peer review comments were basically a list of reasons why I should quit.
Self-deprecating academic humor.
The peer review comments were so extensive that we need another month.
The peer review comments were so extensive that we need another month.
Using the phrase to justify a timeline change.
Peer review comments were great! We are heading to publication!
Peer review comments were great! We are heading to publication!
Short, excited professional update.
自分をテスト
Choose the most professional adjective to complete the sentence for a team meeting.
The peer review comments were ___, so we should implement the changes immediately.
'Constructive' is the standard professional term for feedback that helps you improve.
Complete the sentence to show the feedback was very detailed.
The peer review comments were ___ and covered every page of the manuscript.
'Exhaustive' means very thorough and detailed, fitting the context of 'every page'.
🎉 スコア: /2
ビジュアル学習ツール
Formality Level of 'Peer review comments were'
Talking to friends about a text message.
My friend's comments were...
Talking to a coworker about a draft.
The feedback was...
Academic or professional reporting.
Peer review comments were...
Where to use 'Peer review comments were'
Academic Journal
The peer review comments were favorable.
Grant Proposal
Peer review comments were critical of the budget.
Medical Research
The peer review comments were focused on safety.
Conference Submission
Peer review comments were mixed.
よくある質問
10 問It means your work was checked by people with the same level of expertise as you. For example, a doctor's paper is reviewed by other doctors.
Not usually. A boss is a supervisor, not a 'peer.' Use My supervisor's feedback was instead.
Yes, usually. Even if there is only one major point, we say comments because there are typically multiple notes or a general critique.
It means you don't know who wrote the comments. You would still say The peer review comments were... regardless of whether it was blind or not.
Yes, if the business has a formal process for reviewing proposals or code. It sounds very professional.
You could say the comments were unhelpful, vague, or even disparaging if they were really mean.
You usually say, 'We have addressed the peer review comments by...' followed by the changes you made.
Yes, it functions as the subject of the sentence. You treat it as a plural noun.
It is better to say The comments indicated or The comments suggested. Using said is a bit too informal for this phrase.
You can say they were neutral or mixed. For example, The peer review comments were mixed but generally encouraging.
関連フレーズ
Editorial feedback
Comments specifically from the editor of a publication.
Critical acclaim
Very positive reviews from experts or critics.
Expert consensus
When all the reviewers or experts agree on a point.
Blind review
A review process where names are hidden to prevent bias.
コメント (0)
ログインしてコメント無料で言語学習を始めよう
無料で始める