Dans le chapitre
Handling Multiple Pronouns and Special Verbs
Double object pronoun order (le/la/les before lui/leur)
In French 3rd-person double pronouns, always place the 'what' (le/la/les) before the 'to whom' (lui/leur).
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Direct pronouns (le, la, les) always come before indirect ones (lui, leur).
- This rule only applies when both objects are in the third person.
- Place the pronoun pair immediately before the conjugated verb or infinitive.
- Negative sentences wrap 'ne...pas' around the pronouns and the verb.
Quick Reference
| Direct Object (What) | Indirect Object (Who) | Combined Pair | Example Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| le (it, masc) | lui (to him/her) | le lui | it to him/her |
| la (it, fem) | lui (to him/her) | la lui | it to him/her |
| les (them) | lui (to him/her) | les lui | them to him/her |
| le (it, masc) | leur (to them) | le leur | it to them |
| la (it, fem) | leur (to them) | la leur | it to them |
| les (them) | leur (to them) | les leur | them to them |
Exemples clés
3 sur 10Je le lui donne.
I give it to him.
Tu la leur prêtes ?
Are you lending it to them?
Il ne les lui dit pas.
He doesn't tell them to her.
The 'L' Rule
Notice how all these pronouns start with 'L'. It's easy to remember: the L-team (le/la/les) beats the other L-team (lui/leur) for the first spot.
Don't Translate Literally
If you translate 'I give it to him' word-for-word, you'll put the pronouns in the wrong place. Think of the French sentence as a puzzle with a fixed shape.
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Direct pronouns (le, la, les) always come before indirect ones (lui, leur).
- This rule only applies when both objects are in the third person.
- Place the pronoun pair immediately before the conjugated verb or infinitive.
- Negative sentences wrap 'ne...pas' around the pronouns and the verb.
Overview
Imagine you are at a busy French café. You want to tell the waiter to give the menu to your friend. You do not want to repeat the words le menu and à mon ami. You use pronouns instead. In English, we say "Give it to him." In French, the order is different. This rule is about using two pronouns at once. We call these double object pronouns. It sounds complex but it is just a pattern. You just need to know which one goes first. Think of it like a polite line at a bakery. The bread (the object) always gets served before the person waiting (the recipient). This specific rule applies to third-person pronouns. This means le, la, and les paired with lui and leur. Mastering this makes your French sound smooth and natural. It helps you avoid repeating nouns over and over. You will use this when talking about gifts, information, or favors. It is a fundamental skill for any A1 learner. Let’s dive into the mechanics of this grammar traffic light.
How This Grammar Works
In French, pronouns usually sit right before the verb. When you have two, they have a strict hierarchy. For this rule, we look at Direct Objects and Indirect Objects. The Direct Object is the "what." The Indirect Object is the "to whom." When both are in the third person, the "what" comes first. The pronouns le, la, and les represent the things. The pronouns lui and leur represent the people. You simply stack them in front of the action. Je le lui donne means "I give it to him." The le is the thing. The lui is the person. Even if the sentence is long, this order stays. It is like a fixed chemical formula. You cannot mix them up. If you do, the sentence breaks. Native speakers will still understand you. However, it will sound a bit clunky to them. Yes, even native speakers mess this up sometimes when they speak fast! But you can learn the rhythm easily. Just remember: Thing then Person.
Formation Pattern
- 1Identify your Direct Object. Use
lefor masculine,lafor feminine, orlesfor plural. - 2Identify your Indirect Object. Use
luifor "to him/her" orleurfor "to them." - 3Place the Direct Object first.
- 4Place the Indirect Object second.
- 5Put this pair immediately before the conjugated verb.
- 6For negative sentences, put
nebefore the pronouns andpasafter the verb. - 7For compound tenses, put the pronouns before the helping verb like
aiorest. - 8Example:
Je+la+lui+donne=Je la lui donne. - 9Example Negative:
Je+ne+les+leur+donne+pas=Je ne les leur donne pas.
When To Use It
Use this pattern when you want to be efficient. It is perfect for professional emails. You might say, "I am sending the documents to him." In French, you say Je les lui envoie. It works great for daily chores too. "Did you give the keys to the neighbor?" "Yes, I gave them to him." This is Je les lui ai données. It is also vital for storytelling. You describe an object and then say who gets it. Use it when ordering food for a group. You tell the waiter which dish goes to which friend. It makes you sound sophisticated and clear. Think of it as a shortcut for your brain. You don't have to say long names like Monsieur Dupuis every time. Just use lui. It saves time and energy during long conversations. It is especially common with verbs of giving and telling. Verbs like donner, dire, prêter, and envoyer are your best friends here.
When Not To Use It
There are times when the order changes. Do not use this order in positive commands. If you say "Give it to him!", the pronouns go after the verb. In that case, it becomes Donne-le-lui. The order actually stays the same here, but they move behind the action. Also, this specific "Direct before Indirect" rule only applies to the 3rd person. If you use me, te, nous, or vous, the rule flips. We are not covering that today, so stay focused on lui and leur. Do not use pronouns if the person you are talking to doesn't know what the "it" is. You need to establish the noun first. If you just walk up and say Je le lui donne, your friend will be very confused! They will ask, "Give what to whom?" Use the nouns first, then switch to pronouns in the next sentence. Don't use this if you want to emphasize the person specifically. Sometimes saying the full name adds more weight to the sentence.
Common Mistakes
The biggest mistake is following the English word order. In English, we often put the person first. We say "I give him it." In French, Je lui le donne is incorrect. It sounds like "I him it give." This is the most common trap for beginners. Another mistake is mixing up lui and leur. Remember that lui is for one person. leur is for many people. It does not matter if the people are male or female. lui covers both! Some learners forget to put the pronouns before the verb. They put them at the end like in English. Avoid saying Je donne le lui. This is a major grammar red flag. Also, watch out for the plural les. It often gets confused with the indirect leur. Take your time to identify the "what" and the "who" clearly. Think of it like a grammar traffic light. Green means Thing, Yellow means Person, Red means Verb. Go in that order and you will be fine.
Contrast With Similar Patterns
Let’s compare this to English one more time. English is flexible. You can say "I give it to her" or "I give her it." French is not flexible. You have one choice: Je le lui donne. Compared to other French pronoun rules, this is actually the "standard" one. In most other cases, the "person" pronouns like me or nous come first. This le lui pattern is the exception that you need to memorize. It is different from the "Y" and "En" pronouns too. Those always come last in the sequence. So, if you have le, lui, and y, it becomes le lui y. But don't worry about that yet! Just focus on the fact that le/la/les are the stars of the show. They get the front-row seats. The lui/leur pronouns are the supporting cast. They sit just behind the stars. This hierarchy is unique to the third person.
Quick FAQ
Q. Does lui mean him or her?
A. It means both! It is gender-neutral for indirect objects.
Q. Can I use l' before lui?
A. No, le and la do not shorten before lui because lui starts with a consonant.
Q. What if I have two verbs?
A. Put the pronouns before the infinitive (the second verb). Example: Je vais le lui donner.
Q. Is leur the same as "their"?
A. It looks the same, but here it means "to them." Context is king!
Q. Is this formal?
A. No, it is used in both casual and formal French. Everyone uses it.
Q. Can I say le leur?
A. Yes! It means "it to them." It sounds very French and elegant.
Reference Table
| Direct Object (What) | Indirect Object (Who) | Combined Pair | Example Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| le (it, masc) | lui (to him/her) | le lui | it to him/her |
| la (it, fem) | lui (to him/her) | la lui | it to him/her |
| les (them) | lui (to him/her) | les lui | them to him/her |
| le (it, masc) | leur (to them) | le leur | it to them |
| la (it, fem) | leur (to them) | la leur | it to them |
| les (them) | leur (to them) | les leur | them to them |
The 'L' Rule
Notice how all these pronouns start with 'L'. It's easy to remember: the L-team (le/la/les) beats the other L-team (lui/leur) for the first spot.
Don't Translate Literally
If you translate 'I give it to him' word-for-word, you'll put the pronouns in the wrong place. Think of the French sentence as a puzzle with a fixed shape.
Rhythm is Key
Say 'le lui', 'la lui', 'les lui' out loud several times. It has a specific bounce. Once your ears get used to the sound, your brain will stop overthinking the rule.
Polite Shortcuts
In French culture, repeating nouns can sound repetitive or heavy. Using double pronouns shows you are paying attention to the flow of the conversation.
Exemples
10Je le lui donne.
Focus: le lui
I give it to him.
Standard order: 'le' (it) before 'lui' (to him).
Tu la leur prêtes ?
Focus: la leur
Are you lending it to them?
Using 'la' for a feminine object like 'la voiture'.
Il ne les lui dit pas.
Focus: ne les lui dit pas
He doesn't tell them to her.
The pronouns stay together inside the 'ne...pas' structure.
Nous le leur avons envoyé.
Focus: le leur avons
We sent it to them.
Pronouns go before the auxiliary verb 'avons'.
Veuillez les lui remettre en main propre.
Focus: les lui
Please hand them to him in person.
Common in business contexts for documents.
✗ Je lui la montre. → ✓ Je la lui montre.
Focus: la lui
I show it to her.
Never put the person before the thing in 3rd person.
✗ Il donne le leur. → ✓ Il le leur donne.
Focus: le leur donne
He gives it to them.
Pronouns must come before the verb, not after.
Je vais les lui acheter.
Focus: les lui acheter
I am going to buy them for him.
When using 'aller' + infinitive, pronouns go before the second verb.
Si elle a la clé, elle la lui rendra.
Focus: la lui rendra
If she has the key, she will give it back to him.
The future tense doesn't change the pronoun placement.
Pourquoi ne les leur as-tu pas montrés ?
Focus: les leur
Why didn't you show them to them?
Complex question structure with negation and past tense.
Teste-toi
Complete the sentence: 'I give the letter (la lettre) to the teacher (lui).'
Je ___ donne.
'La lettre' is feminine (la) and it comes before the person (lui).
Choose the correct negative form for: 'He doesn't send the gifts (les cadeaux) to them (leur).'
Il ___ envoie pas.
Pronouns stay together after 'ne' and 'les' precedes 'leur'.
Where do the pronouns go in: 'I want to show it (le) to her (lui).'
Je veux ___ montrer.
In two-verb sentences, pronouns sit before the infinitive (montrer).
🎉 Score : /3
Aides visuelles
English vs French Order
How to Place Your Pronouns
Are both pronouns 3rd person (le/la/les/lui/leur)?
Which is the Direct Object (the thing)?
Place 'le/la/les' before 'lui/leur'. Ready?
Put the pair before the verb!
Common Verbs for Double Pronouns
Giving
- • donner
- • offrir
- • prêter
Sending
- • envoyer
- • apporter
- • rendre
Telling
- • dire
- • expliquer
- • montrer
Questions fréquentes
21 questionsNo, the order is strictly fixed in French. You must say le lui regardless of emphasis.
No, in this context lui means both 'to him' and 'to her'. It is one of the few gender-neutral spots in French!
You shorten the direct pronoun to l'. For example, Je l'lui apporte (though the 'l' and 'l' sound blends, it's written l'lui).
No, leur is only the indirect object (to them). For plural objects, use les.
Yes, but y comes after both. For example: Je le lui y apporte (I bring it to him there).
Great question! French has a specific map for pronouns. 1st and 2nd person (me, te, nous, vous) come before everything, but for 3rd person, the objects go first.
You use Je le leur donne. Remember that leur means 'to them' here.
In a command like 'Give it to him!', it is Donne-le-lui. The thing still comes before the person.
Yes! Je le lui dis means 'I tell it to him'. It is very common.
It is les leur. Example: Je les leur donne (I give them to them).
It's standard French. In very casual speech, people might drop the ne, but the pronoun order le lui stays the same.
Yes. Place them before the auxiliary: Je le lui ai offert (I offered it to her).
The structure is Je ne veux pas le lui donner. The ne...pas surrounds the first verb.
Never. As an indirect pronoun (to them), leur is always invariable. No 's' allowed!
Think of it as 'Direct before Indirect'. D comes before I in the alphabet. It's a handy trick!
Yes, if you consider the animal the recipient of an action, like giving a bone to a dog: Je le lui donne.
People will understand you, but it sounds like a literal translation. Don't sweat it, just keep practicing!
Very. Use it for feminine things like la voiture or la pomme. Je la lui donne.
Absolutely. Je le lui envoie is how you say 'I am sending it to him/her'.
Putting the person first because of English influence. Always double-check your 'What' and 'Who'!
Yes. On le lui donne means 'We give it to him' or 'One gives it to him'.
Grammaire lie
Subject Pronouns: je, tu, il/elle, nous, vous, ils/elles
Overview French subject pronouns are the essential building blocks of almost every sentence you will ever speak or writ...
Tu vs Vous: Formal and Informal You
Overview Imagine you are in a sunny Parisian cafe. You want to order a buttery croissant. You catch the waiter's eye. No...
Using Nous Instead of On in Formal French
Overview Ever noticed how French people seem to have two ways of saying everything? One sounds like a casual chat at a...
Subject Inversion with Voici and Voilà
Overview Welcome to the magic world of pointing things out! In French, we have two superstar words for this: `voici` an...
Le pronom de rappel
Overview Imagine you are at a busy French cafe. You want to make sure the waiter knows exactly what you want. You point...
Commentaires (0)
Connectez-vous pour CommenterCommencez à apprendre les langues gratuitement
Commence Gratuitement