Relative Clauses with Prepositions
The preposition dictates the case of the relative pronoun and must always precede it after the comma.
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Place the preposition before the relative pronoun at the start of the clause.
- The preposition determines the case (Accusative, Dative, or Genitive) of the pronoun.
- Use 'wo-' compounds for things and 'preposition + pronoun' for people.
- Always place the conjugated verb at the very end of the relative clause.
Quick Reference
| Case | Masculine | Feminine | Neuter | Plural |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Accusative | durch den | durch die | durch das | durch die |
| Dative | mit dem | mit der | mit dem | mit denen |
| Genitive | trotz dessen | trotz deren | trotz dessen | trotz deren |
| Two-Way (Loc.) | in dem | in der | in dem | in denen |
| Two-Way (Dir.) | in den | in die | in das | in die |
مثالهای کلیدی
3 از 8Das ist der Kollege, mit dem ich das Projekt leite.
That is the colleague with whom I am leading the project.
Dort steht der Tisch, für den ich mich entschieden habe.
There stands the table that I decided on.
Das ist die Firma, innerhalb deren wir expandieren wollen.
That is the company within which we want to expand.
The 'Denen' Trap
In the dative plural, the relative pronoun is 'denen', not 'die' or 'den'. It’s a common C1 exam pitfall!
No Dangling!
Never leave the preposition at the end like in English. It must always sit right after the comma, hugging the pronoun.
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Place the preposition before the relative pronoun at the start of the clause.
- The preposition determines the case (Accusative, Dative, or Genitive) of the pronoun.
- Use 'wo-' compounds for things and 'preposition + pronoun' for people.
- Always place the conjugated verb at the very end of the relative clause.
Overview
You have already mastered basic relative clauses. You know how to use der, die, and das. But what happens when a verb needs a preposition? Think about verbs like warten auf or sprechen mit. In English, we often end sentences with prepositions. We say, "The friend I'm waiting for." In German, that is a big no-no. You must move the preposition to the front. This makes your German sound sophisticated and precise. It is a vital skill for C1 learners. It allows you to connect complex ideas smoothly. You will sound less like a textbook and more like a pro. Think of this as the "bridge" between two thoughts. It connects a person or thing to an action involving them.
How This Grammar Works
This grammar point relies on two things. First, you need a relative pronoun. Second, you need a preposition. The preposition always comes first in the clause. It acts like a gatekeeper for the pronoun. The most important rule is the case. The preposition dictates the case of the relative pronoun. If the preposition takes the dative, the pronoun is dative. If it takes the accusative, the pronoun is accusative. It does not matter what the main clause does. The relative clause is its own little kingdom. For people, we always use the relative pronoun. For things, we often have a choice. You can use the preposition plus the pronoun. Or, you can use a wo- compound like worüber. At C1, you should be comfortable with both. It is like choosing between a suit and a tuxedo. Both are formal, but one is slightly sharper.
Formation Pattern
- 1Building these sentences is a five-step process. Follow these steps to avoid grammar traffic jams:
- 2Identify the noun you want to describe. This is your reference point.
- 3Determine the gender and number of that noun (masculine, feminine, neuter, or plural).
- 4Identify the preposition required by the verb in your relative clause.
- 5Apply the case required by that preposition to the relative pronoun.
- 6Place the preposition and pronoun right after the comma. Then, put the conjugated verb at the very end.
- 7Example:
Der Kollege(masculine) +warten auf(accusative) =Der Kollege, auf den ich warte...
When To Use It
Use this pattern when you need to be specific. It is perfect for professional environments. Imagine you are in a job interview. You want to talk about a project. You would say, "The project for which I was responsible." In German: Das Projekt, für das ich verantwortlich war. It sounds much better than two short sentences. Use it when telling stories to friends. "The bar in which we met" sounds better than "We met in a bar. The bar was cool." It is also essential for academic writing. It helps you avoid repeating the same noun over and over. Basically, use it whenever you want to show off your C1 muscles. It provides clarity in complex descriptions.
When Not To Use It
Do not overdo it in very casual speech. If you are just grabbing a Döner, keep it simple. Overusing complex relative clauses can make you sound stiff. It is like wearing a ball gown to a grocery store. Also, avoid them if the sentence becomes a labyrinth. If you have three relative clauses in one sentence, stop. Your listener will get lost. Break it up into two sentences instead. Native speakers value clarity over complexity. If you are unsure of the preposition's case, pause. It is better to use a simpler structure than a wrong case. A wrong case can change the entire meaning.
Common Mistakes
One huge mistake is the "English dangling preposition." Never put the preposition at the end of the clause. Der Mann, den ich warte auf is 100% wrong. Another mistake is forgetting the case change. Many people use dem when they need den. Remember: für is always accusative. mit is always dative. Even native speakers trip over this after a long day! Another trap is the wo- compound. Do not use womit for people. You cannot say Der Lehrer, womit ich sprach. You must say Der Lehrer, mit dem ich sprach. Using wo- for people sounds very strange. It is like calling a person an "it."
Contrast With Similar Patterns
You might confuse this with da- compounds. Davon, darüber, and damit point back to a previous sentence. Relative clauses with prepositions connect ideas within the same sentence. Think of da- compounds as a pointer. Think of relative clauses as a glue. There is also a difference between using welcher and der. Welcher is very formal and rare in speech. Stick to der/die/das for most situations. Also, compare this to simple relative clauses. Der Mann, der dort steht (Nominative) is easy. Der Mann, mit dem ich tanze (Dative) adds that extra layer of detail.
Quick FAQ
Q. Can I use deren with a preposition?
A. Yes! For example: Die Frau, mit deren Hund ich spiele. It shows possession.
Q. Do I always need a comma?
A. Yes, always. In German, commas before relative clauses are mandatory. Think of the comma as a speed bump.
Q. What if the verb has two prepositions?
A. Pick the one that fits your meaning. Usually, you only need one for the relative clause.
Q. Is woran better than an das?
A. For things, woran is more common and sounds more natural. For people, you must use an den/die.
Reference Table
| Case | Masculine | Feminine | Neuter | Plural |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Accusative | durch den | durch die | durch das | durch die |
| Dative | mit dem | mit der | mit dem | mit denen |
| Genitive | trotz dessen | trotz deren | trotz dessen | trotz deren |
| Two-Way (Loc.) | in dem | in der | in dem | in denen |
| Two-Way (Dir.) | in den | in die | in das | in die |
The 'Denen' Trap
In the dative plural, the relative pronoun is 'denen', not 'die' or 'den'. It’s a common C1 exam pitfall!
No Dangling!
Never leave the preposition at the end like in English. It must always sit right after the comma, hugging the pronoun.
Abstract Things
When talking about abstract ideas (like 'the situation'), 'worüber' or 'woran' sounds much more natural than 'über die' or 'an die'.
Formal vs. Casual
In casual speech, Germans might avoid complex relative clauses by using two sentences. Use them in writing to show high proficiency.
مثالها
8Das ist der Kollege, mit dem ich das Projekt leite.
Focus: mit dem
That is the colleague with whom I am leading the project.
The preposition 'mit' always requires the dative case.
Dort steht der Tisch, für den ich mich entschieden habe.
Focus: für den
There stands the table that I decided on.
The verb 'entscheiden für' takes the accusative case.
Das ist die Firma, innerhalb deren wir expandieren wollen.
Focus: innerhalb deren
That is the company within which we want to expand.
Genitive prepositions use 'deren' for feminine/plural in relative clauses.
Der Umstand, auf welchen Sie sich beziehen, ist bekannt.
Focus: auf welchen
The circumstance to which you are referring is known.
Using 'welchen' adds a very formal, academic tone.
✗ Der Mann, den ich warte auf. → ✓ Der Mann, auf den ich warte.
Focus: auf den
The man I am waiting for.
Prepositions cannot dangle at the end in German.
✗ Das ist die Frau, womit ich arbeite. → ✓ Das ist die Frau, mit der ich arbeite.
Focus: mit der
That is the woman I work with.
Do not use 'wo-' compounds for people.
Das ist ein Problem, worüber wir dringend sprechen müssen.
Focus: worüber
That is a problem about which we urgently need to speak.
'Worüber' is preferred over 'über das' for abstract things.
Das sind die Freunde, von denen ich dir erzählt habe.
Focus: von denen
Those are the friends I told you about.
The plural dative relative pronoun is 'denen', not 'die'.
خودت رو بسنج
Choose the correct preposition and pronoun combination.
Die Chefin, ___ ich gestern telefoniert habe, ist sehr nett.
The verb 'telefonieren' takes the preposition 'mit' + Dative. 'Chefin' is feminine.
Select the correct form for an abstract object.
Das ist das Thema, ___ wir uns im Seminar beschäftigen.
While 'mit dem' is grammatically correct, 'womit' is the more natural C1 choice for things/topics.
Complete the sentence using the correct plural form.
Die Kollegen, ___ wir die Präsentation vorbereiten, sind kompetent.
'Für' takes the accusative. The plural accusative relative pronoun is 'die'.
🎉 امتیاز: /3
ابزارهای بصری یادگیری
People vs. Things
How to Build the Clause
Is the reference a person?
Does the preposition take Dative?
Is it plural?
Common Verb + Preposition Pairs
Dative Verbs
- • sprechen mit
- • träumen von
- • arbeiten bei
Accusative Verbs
- • warten auf
- • denken an
- • sich freuen über
سوالات متداول
20 سوالIt is a sub-clause that describes a noun using a verb that requires a preposition. For example, Der Mann, mit dem ich rede (The man with whom I am talking).
German syntax is strict about verb-final placement in sub-clauses. The preposition must stay with its object, which is the relative pronoun at the start.
The preposition determines the case. For example, für always takes the accusative, so you use für den/die/das.
Yes, welcher is a valid relative pronoun. However, it sounds very formal and is mostly used in literature to avoid repeating der too many times.
Use mit dem for people or specific masculine/neuter objects. Use womit for abstract things or general objects.
The case depends on the verb's meaning. If it's a fixed verb-preposition idiom like warten auf, it's almost always accusative: auf den.
Yes, in relative clauses, denen is the specific form for the dative plural. For example: Die Leute, mit denen ich verreise.
No, never. In English, you can say 'The book I read.' In German, you must say Das Buch, das ich las.
They work the same way! You would say Die Krise, wegen derer wir uns sorgen (The crisis because of which we worry).
Yes, a comma is mandatory before every relative clause in German. It separates the main clause from the description.
If the preposition starts with a vowel, add an 'r'. For example, über becomes worüber and an becomes woran.
Yes, because the preposition mit is always dative. The gender of the noun then decides if it's dem (m/n) or der (f).
No, damit or davon are used to refer to a previous sentence. Relative clauses require mit dem or womit.
Yes, the conjugated verb must be the very last word in the relative clause. If there's a modal verb, it goes after the infinitive.
You would typically use a wo- compound. For example: Das Ganze, worüber wir uns geeinigt haben.
It is always mit denen. Mit die is a common mistake because people forget the dative plural 'n'.
It is very similar to the formal English 'with whom' or 'for which'. German just uses this structure much more frequently.
Only if the reference is an indefinite pronoun like alles or nichts. Example: Das ist alles, worüber ich bescheid weiß.
Mixing up the dative and accusative after two-way prepositions. Remember that most prepositional verbs have a fixed case.
Try rewriting two simple sentences into one using a relative clause. For example: 'Ich habe einen Freund. Ich warte auf ihn.' becomes 'Ich habe einen Freund, auf den ich warte.'
قواعد مرتبط
Konjunktiv I for Indirect Speech - Present Tense
Overview Ever played the game of 'Telephone'? You know, where you whisper a secret and it changes completely by the end...
Consecutive Konjunktiv I
Overview Welcome to one of the most elegant corners of the German language. You might be at the A1 level, but that does...
Würde-Construction Avoidance
Overview Ever felt like a bit of a robot when speaking German? You want to be polite. You want to sound natural. But so...
Konjunktiv I with "haben" - Present
Overview Welcome to the world of "he said, she said." Imagine you are a detective. Or maybe a gossip columnist. You wan...
Konjunktiv I Pluperfect
Overview Do you enjoy telling stories to your friends? Sometimes you need to tell a story about a story. Imagine your fr...
نظرات (0)
برای نظر دادن وارد شویدیادگیری زبانها را رایگان شروع کنید
شروع رایگان یادگیری