Prepositions in Relative Clauses (Formal)
In formal English, place prepositions before 'whom' or 'which' to create a professional and sophisticated tone.
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Move the preposition from the end to before the relative pronoun.
- Use 'whom' for people and 'which' for things in this structure.
- Never use 'who' or 'that' immediately after a preposition.
- Save this pattern for formal writing, like essays and professional emails.
Quick Reference
| Preposition | Relative Pronoun | Formal Example | Informal Equivalent |
|---|---|---|---|
| To | Whom | The person to whom I wrote. | The person I wrote to. |
| In | Which | The box in which I kept it. | The box I kept it in. |
| With | Whom | The client with whom I met. | The client I met with. |
| For | Which | The reason for which he left. | The reason he left for. |
| From | Whom | The man from whom I heard it. | The man I heard it from. |
| At | Which | The speed at which we drove. | The speed we drove at. |
关键例句
3 / 8The manager to whom you should report is in the office.
Der Manager, bei dem Sie sich melden sollten, ist im Büro.
The environment in which we work is very supportive.
Das Umfeld, in dem wir arbeiten, ist sehr unterstützend.
The candidate for whom I voted won the election.
Der Kandidat, für den ich gestimmt habe, hat die Wahl gewonnen.
The 'Him' Test
If you can answer the question with 'him' (to him), use 'whom'. If you answer with 'it', use 'which'. It works every time!
Avoid Double Prepositions
If you move 'in' to the front, delete it from the end. Saying 'In which I live in' is like wearing two pairs of sunglasses.
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Move the preposition from the end to before the relative pronoun.
- Use 'whom' for people and 'which' for things in this structure.
- Never use 'who' or 'that' immediately after a preposition.
- Save this pattern for formal writing, like essays and professional emails.
Overview
Ever felt like your English needs a tuxedo? Sometimes, casual English is just too relaxed. Imagine you are writing a cover letter. Or perhaps you are giving a formal presentation. In these moments, you need a specific grammar tool. This tool involves moving prepositions in relative clauses. Usually, we leave prepositions at the end of sentences. We say, "The person I talked to." In formal English, we move that preposition. It goes right before the relative pronoun. It becomes, "The person to whom I talked." It sounds sophisticated. It sounds professional. It is like a grammar traffic light. It tells the reader to slow down and pay attention. Don't worry, it is easier than it looks. You just need to follow a few simple steps. Let’s dive into the world of formal structures together.
How This Grammar Works
In casual English, we often end sentences with prepositions. This is called a "dangling preposition." It is perfectly fine for daily chats. However, formal writing prefers a different structure. We take the preposition from the end. We place it before the relative pronoun. This relative pronoun must be whom for people. It must be which for things. You cannot use who or that here. This change shifts the tone immediately. It moves from "coffee with a friend" to "meeting with the CEO." Think of it as rearranging furniture. The room stays the same. The layout just looks more organized. Yes, even native speakers find this a bit fancy. But using it correctly makes you stand out. It shows you have a high level of control.
Formation Pattern
- 1Creating these clauses follows a very logical path. Follow these four steps to get it right every time.
- 2Identify the relative clause in your sentence.
- 3Find the preposition at the end of that clause.
- 4Move that preposition to the front of the clause.
- 5Choose the correct formal pronoun:
whomorwhich. - 6For example, start with: "The project I worked on."
- 7Step 1: The relative clause is "I worked on."
- 8Step 2: The preposition is
on. - 9Step 3: Move
onto the front. - 10Step 4: Use
whichbecause a project is a thing. - 11Result: "The project on which I worked."
- 12It is like a puzzle. You just need to move one piece. Once you see the pattern, you cannot unsee it. It becomes a fun mental game.
When To Use It
Context is everything in language. You wouldn't wear a ballgown to the gym. Similarly, don't use this grammar at a party. Use it when the stakes are high. It is perfect for academic essays. Use it in legal documents or contracts. It is great for professional emails to a boss. If you are applying for a visa, use it. If you are writing a thesis, use it. It signals that you are serious. It shows respect for the reader. In a job interview, it sounds very impressive. "The team with whom I worked was great." This sounds much better than "The team I worked with." It gives your speech a rhythmic, polished quality. Use it sparingly, though. You don't want to sound like a 19th-century poet. Balance is key to modern English.
When Not To Use It
Avoid this structure in casual conversations. If you are ordering pizza, keep it simple. Don't say, "The pizza for which I paid is late." The delivery driver might look at you strangely. Avoid it in text messages to friends. It can make you seem cold or distant. It can also feel a bit "stiff" in modern fiction. Most native speakers use the informal version 90% of the time. If you use it too much, you might sound like a robot. Or a very confused time traveler. Use the informal version for hobbies and family. Use the informal version for social media posts. Grammar is a tool, not a cage. Choose the right tool for the right job.
Common Mistakes
One big mistake is using who after a preposition. You must never say "The person to who I spoke." That is a major grammar crime. Always use whom after a preposition. Another mistake is using that. You cannot say "The car in that I sat." It must be "The car in which I sat." Some people also forget to remove the preposition from the end. They say, "The house in which I live in." This is redundant. It is like wearing two hats at once. Just use the preposition once at the front. Finally, don't force it. If the sentence becomes too long, it might break. If it feels like a tongue-twister, simplify it. Even formal English should be clear.
Contrast With Similar Patterns
Let’s compare the formal style with the informal style.
Informal: "The man I was looking for."
Formal: "The man for whom I was looking."
Informal: "The city I moved to."
Formal: "The city to which I moved."
Notice the pronoun that. In informal English, we use that often. "The book that I read." But in the formal version, that disappears. We only use which or whom. Also, notice the "zero relative pronoun." In informal English, we often drop the pronoun. "The girl I talked to." In formal English, you must keep the pronoun. "The girl to whom I talked." You cannot drop it. It acts as an anchor for the preposition. This makes the formal version longer. It also makes it much more precise.
Quick FAQ
Q. Is whom dying out?
A. In speech, yes. In formal writing, it is alive and well.
Q. Can I use where instead of in which?
A. Yes! "The city where I live" is a great middle ground.
Q. Does this apply to whose?
A. Yes. "The author, with whose work I am familiar."
Q. Is it wrong to end a sentence with a preposition?
A. No. That is an old myth from the 18th century. But moving it sounds more professional.
Q. What if there are two prepositions?
A. Move the one that is part of the verb phrase. "The deal into which we entered."
Reference Table
| Preposition | Relative Pronoun | Formal Example | Informal Equivalent |
|---|---|---|---|
| To | Whom | The person to whom I wrote. | The person I wrote to. |
| In | Which | The box in which I kept it. | The box I kept it in. |
| With | Whom | The client with whom I met. | The client I met with. |
| For | Which | The reason for which he left. | The reason he left for. |
| From | Whom | The man from whom I heard it. | The man I heard it from. |
| At | Which | The speed at which we drove. | The speed we drove at. |
The 'Him' Test
If you can answer the question with 'him' (to him), use 'whom'. If you answer with 'it', use 'which'. It works every time!
Avoid Double Prepositions
If you move 'in' to the front, delete it from the end. Saying 'In which I live in' is like wearing two pairs of sunglasses.
Academic Writing
Use this structure in your university essays. It instantly makes your arguments sound more authoritative and researched.
The 'Stiff' Factor
Native speakers rarely use this in spoken English. If you use it while grabbing a burger, you might sound like a movie villain!
例句
8The manager to whom you should report is in the office.
Focus: to whom
Der Manager, bei dem Sie sich melden sollten, ist im Büro.
This is the classic formal structure for people.
The environment in which we work is very supportive.
Focus: in which
Das Umfeld, in dem wir arbeiten, ist sehr unterstützend.
Used for places or abstract concepts.
The candidate for whom I voted won the election.
Focus: for whom
Der Kandidat, für den ich gestimmt habe, hat die Wahl gewonnen.
A very common formal usage in political contexts.
This is the issue about which we are most concerned.
Focus: about which
Dies ist das Thema, über das wir am meisten besorgt sind.
Moves the preposition 'about' to the front.
The person with whose car we traveled is my uncle.
Focus: with whose
Die Person, mit deren Auto wir gereist sind, ist mein Onkel.
Advanced use with the possessive 'whose'.
The lady to whom I spoke was very helpful.
Focus: to whom
Die Dame, mit der ich sprach, war sehr hilfreich.
Never use 'who' after a preposition.
The house in which I live is very old.
Focus: in which
Das Haus, in dem ich wohne, ist sehr alt.
Don't repeat the preposition at the end.
The conditions under which they work are improving.
Focus: under which
Die Bedingungen, unter denen sie arbeiten, verbessern sich.
Formal phrase often used in reports.
自我测试
Change the informal sentence to formal: 'The company I work for is global.'
The company ___ ___ I work is global.
We use 'for' because it was at the end, and 'which' because a company is a thing.
Choose the correct formal relative pronoun for a person.
The professor to ___ I sent the email has replied.
After a preposition like 'to', we must use 'whom' when referring to a person.
Identify the mistake: 'The platform on that we stand is shaky.'
The platform ___ ___ we stand is shaky.
You cannot use 'that' after a preposition; you must use 'which' for objects.
🎉 得分: /3
视觉学习工具
Informal vs. Formal Style
The Formal Preposition Path
Is the context formal?
Is it a person?
Use [Preposition] + whom.
Common Formal Pairings
Time/Place
- • In which
- • At which
Connection
- • With whom
- • To whom
常见问题
20 个问题It is a word like in, to, or with that links the relative clause to the rest of the sentence. In formal English, we move it to the front.
It is a stylistic choice that comes from Latin influence. It makes the sentence sound more structured and professional.
No, that is incorrect in formal English. You must use whom after a preposition, such as in to whom.
Not at all! It is perfectly correct for daily conversation. It is only 'informal' compared to the 'formal' version.
Use which after a preposition when you are talking about objects, animals, or ideas. Example: the car in which I sat.
No, that cannot follow a preposition. You must change it to which or whom.
Yes, especially in writing. You will see it in newspapers, books, and legal documents every day.
Nothing bad happens! You just sound more casual. In an exam, however, you might lose points for style.
The preposition depends on the verb. If the verb is listen to, use to. If it is work with, use with.
Yes, you can say the man with whose daughter I spoke. It is very formal but correct.
It might sound a bit too serious. It is better to stick to the informal version for friends.
Yes, many Romance languages like French and Spanish always put the preposition first. English is unique because it allows both.
It is a preposition left at the end of a sentence, like the chair I sat on. Some old-fashioned teachers dislike them.
Yes, the room in which I sleep can be the room where I sleep. Where is a great way to sound natural.
Exactly! It is one of the most common formal phrases in English using this rule.
Only move the one that connects to the object. For example: the situation with which I had to put up.
Yes, using formal relative clauses can help you get a higher score in the writing section.
Yes, the group of which I am a member is a very common formal construction.
Usually, yes. Formal English tends to be more wordy than casual English.
It takes practice to remember to use whom. Just keep the 'Him/Whom' rule in mind!
相关语法
What as a Relative Pronoun
Overview Ever felt like you're missing a word in English? You want to talk about a thing. But you don't know the name o...
Relative Pronouns: Which for Things
Overview Imagine you are telling a friend about a new movie. You say, "I saw a movie. It was great." That is fine, but...
Prepositions at the End (Informal)
Overview You might have been told a scary lie. Someone once said: "Never end a sentence with a preposition!" Well, I ha...
Defining Relative Clauses
Overview Imagine you are standing in a crowded room. You want to tell your friend about a specific person. You say, "Loo...
Omitting Relative Pronouns (Object Position)
Overview Ever feel like English has too many words? You are not alone. Sometimes, we use words that do not need to be t...
评论 (0)
登录后评论免费开始学习语言
免费开始学习