B1 relative_clauses 6 min read

Defining Relative Clauses

Defining relative clauses provide essential information to identify a specific noun without using any commas.

The Rule in 30 Seconds

  • Defining clauses identify exactly which person or thing you mean.
  • They use pronouns like `who`, `which`, `that`, `where`, and `whose`.
  • Never use commas around a defining relative clause.
  • The information is essential for the sentence to make sense.

Quick Reference

Pronoun Used For Example Sentence
who People The girl `who` called you is my sister.
which Things / Animals The cake `which` I baked is on the table.
that People / Things The phone `that` I want is very expensive.
where Places This is the cafe `where` we first met.
whose Possession The man `whose` car was stolen is upset.
when Time I remember the day `when` we graduated.

Key Examples

3 of 8
1

The man `who` lives next door is a pilot.

El hombre que vive al lado es piloto.

2

I lost the watch `that` my father gave me.

Perdí el reloj que me regaló mi padre.

3

The woman `whose` dog is barking is my boss.

La mujer cuyo perro está ladrando es mi jefa.

💡

The 'That' Shortcut

If you are unsure whether to use `who` or `which`, use `that`. It works for both people and things in defining clauses!

⚠️

The Comma Trap

Adding commas to a defining clause changes the meaning. 'The students who passed' vs 'The students, who passed'. One is essential, one is extra!

The Rule in 30 Seconds

  • Defining clauses identify exactly which person or thing you mean.
  • They use pronouns like `who`, `which`, `that`, `where`, and `whose`.
  • Never use commas around a defining relative clause.
  • The information is essential for the sentence to make sense.

Overview

Imagine you are standing in a crowded room. You want to tell your friend about a specific person. You say, "Look at the woman." Your friend sees ten women. They have no idea who you mean. You need to define her. You say, "Look at the woman who is wearing the bright yellow dress." Now, the mystery is gone. This is the power of a defining relative clause. It gives us the essential information. It tells us exactly which person or thing we are talking about. Without this information, the sentence is incomplete. It might even be confusing. These clauses are like the DNA of a sentence. They provide the identity. They help us distinguish one thing from another. In English, we use them every single day. They make our speech precise and clear. Think of them as a spotlight. They shine a light on the specific noun you want to highlight. Yes, even native speakers mess this up sometimes, but once you master it, you will sound much more natural.

How This Grammar Works

Defining relative clauses act like long adjectives. A normal adjective is one word, like blue or tall. A relative clause is a whole phrase. It usually starts with a relative pronoun. These pronouns are the glue. They connect the main sentence to the description. The most common ones are who, which, and that. We also use where for places and whose for possession. These clauses always come right after the noun they describe. This is a strict rule. You cannot move them to the end of the sentence. If you do, the sentence breaks. They are "defining" because they limit the noun. They tell us "not any woman, but the one in yellow." This grammar is your best friend for being specific. It helps you avoid repeating yourself. Instead of two short sentences, you make one smooth one. Think of it like a grammar traffic light; it tells the listener when to stop and pay attention to the details.

Formation Pattern

  1. 1Start with the main part of your sentence.
  2. 2Identify the noun you want to explain.
  3. 3Choose your relative pronoun carefully.
  4. 4Use who for people. This is the classic choice.
  5. 5Use which for things and animals.
  6. 6Use that for both people and things. It is very flexible.
  7. 7Use where when you are talking about a location.
  8. 8Use whose to show that something belongs to someone.
  9. 9Put the pronoun immediately after the noun.
  10. 10Add the rest of the descriptive information.
  11. 11Do not add any commas. This is vital.
  12. 12Finish the rest of your main sentence if needed.
  13. 13Example: "The car that I bought yesterday is very fast."

When To Use It

Use this grammar when the listener needs more info. Real-world scenarios are everywhere. Imagine you are at a restaurant. You tell the waiter, "I want the pasta that comes with spicy sauce." This ensures you don't get the plain one. Think about a job interview. You want to impress the manager. You say, "I am a worker who always meets deadlines." This defines your professional identity. When you are traveling, you might ask, "Is this the platform where the London train stops?" It keeps you on the right track. You also use it when describing your family. "He is the cousin who lives in Australia." It helps people understand your social circle. Use it whenever you need to pick one thing out of a group. It is the ultimate tool for clarity. It is like giving someone a map instead of just pointing in a general direction.

When Not To Use It

Do not use a defining clause for extra, non-essential info. If the noun is already unique, you don't need to define it. For example, "My father who is a doctor is nice." This sounds like you have many fathers! Since you only have one, use a non-defining clause with commas. Also, avoid using them when the context is already 100% clear. If you are holding a red ball, don't say "Give me the ball that is red." Just say "Give me the ball." It saves time and sounds more natural. Don't use what as a relative pronoun. This is a common trap. "The book what I read" is wrong. Always stick to that or which. Finally, don't use them to state the obvious. "The ice that is cold" is redundant and makes you sound a bit like a robot.

Common Mistakes

The "Comma Drama" is the most frequent error. Many people want to put commas around these clauses. Please, resist the urge! Commas tell the reader the info is optional. In defining clauses, the info is mandatory. Another mistake is using the wrong pronoun. Don't use which for your best friend. Use who. Don't use who for your new laptop. Use which or that. Another slip-up is repeating the subject. "The man who he lives here" is incorrect. The word who already acts as the subject. You don't need he. It's like wearing two hats at once. One is enough! Also, be careful with whose. It replaces a possessive, so don't say "The girl whose her car is red." Just say "The girl whose car is red."

Contrast With Similar Patterns

You must know the difference between defining and non-defining clauses. Think of it like a grammar traffic light. A defining clause is a green light. It carries the essential meaning forward. A non-defining clause is like a yellow light. It adds a little extra detail but isn't the main point. Defining: "The students who studied passed." (Only the ones who studied). Non-defining: "The students, who studied, passed." (All the students studied and passed). See the difference? The commas change everything. Also, compare relative clauses to simple adjectives. "The red car" is simple. "The car that has a broken window" is a relative clause. Use the clause when a simple adjective isn't enough. It gives you more room to be descriptive and precise in your storytelling.

Quick FAQ

Q. Can I use that instead of who?

A. Yes, in casual speech, that is very common for people.

Q. When can I delete who or that?

A. You can delete them if they are the object. "The man (who) I met."

Q. Is whose only for people?

A. No, you can use whose for things too. "The house whose roof is red."

Q. Why is this called "defining"?

A. Because it defines exactly which noun we are discussing.

Q. Do I need a pronoun for places?

A. Use where or which plus a preposition like in.

Q. Is this grammar formal?

A. It is used in both formal writing and everyday chat. It is a B1 essential!

Reference Table

Pronoun Used For Example Sentence
who People The girl `who` called you is my sister.
which Things / Animals The cake `which` I baked is on the table.
that People / Things The phone `that` I want is very expensive.
where Places This is the cafe `where` we first met.
whose Possession The man `whose` car was stolen is upset.
when Time I remember the day `when` we graduated.
💡

The 'That' Shortcut

If you are unsure whether to use `who` or `which`, use `that`. It works for both people and things in defining clauses!

⚠️

The Comma Trap

Adding commas to a defining clause changes the meaning. 'The students who passed' vs 'The students, who passed'. One is essential, one is extra!

🎯

Dropping the Pronoun

If the pronoun is followed by a subject (I, you, he), you can usually delete it. 'The book (that) I read' sounds very natural.

💬

Who vs Whom

In modern English, almost everyone uses `who` instead of `whom`. Don't worry about `whom` unless you are writing a very formal academic paper.

أمثلة

8
#1 Basic Person

The man `who` lives next door is a pilot.

Focus: who

El hombre que vive al lado es piloto.

Use `who` to identify which man we are talking about.

#2 Basic Thing

I lost the watch `that` my father gave me.

Focus: that

Perdí el reloj que me regaló mi padre.

`that` is very natural for objects in spoken English.

#3 Possession

The woman `whose` dog is barking is my boss.

Focus: whose

La mujer cuyo perro está ladrando es mi jefa.

`whose` replaces 'her' in this context.

#4 Place

That is the restaurant `where` they serve great sushi.

Focus: where

Ese es el restaurante donde sirven un sushi genial.

`where` defines the specific location.

#5 Formal vs Informal

The person `to whom` I spoke was very helpful.

Focus: whom

La persona con quien hablé fue muy amable.

`whom` is formal; usually we say 'The person I spoke to'.

#6 Correction: Comma

✗ The car, that is red, is mine. → ✓ The car `that` is red is mine.

Focus: that

El coche que es rojo es mío.

Never use commas in defining relative clauses.

#7 Correction: Subject Repeat

✗ The boy who he won the race is happy. → ✓ The boy `who` won the race is happy.

Focus: who

El chico que ganó la carrera está feliz.

Don't repeat the subject 'he' after 'who'.

#8 Advanced: Omission

The movie `(that)` we watched last night was scary.

Focus: (that)

La película que vimos anoche daba miedo.

You can omit the pronoun if it is the object of the clause.

Test Yourself

Choose the correct relative pronoun for the person described.

The teacher ___ teaches chemistry is very strict.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. الإجابة الصحيحة: who

We use `who` because we are referring to a person (the teacher).

Identify the correct pronoun for a possession.

I know a girl ___ brother is a famous actor.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. الإجابة الصحيحة: whose

`whose` is used to show possession (her brother).

Select the pronoun for an object.

The laptop ___ I bought is already broken.

✓ Correct! ✗ Not quite. الإجابة الصحيحة: that

`that` (or `which`) is used for things like laptops.

🎉 Score: /3

Visual Learning Aids

Defining vs. Non-Defining

Defining (Essential)
No Commas The man who is tall.
Specific Identifies which one.
Non-Defining (Extra)
Has Commas My dad, who is tall,...
General Adds extra info.

Choosing Your Pronoun

1

Is it a person?

YES ↓
NO
Use 'which' or 'that'
2

Is it possessive?

YES ↓
NO
Use 'who' or 'that'
3

Use 'whose'

Usage Scenarios

🛍️

Shopping

  • The shirt that fits
  • The shop where I buy
👋

Social

  • The friend who called
  • The person whose car...

Frequently Asked Questions

21 questions

It is a part of a sentence that tells us exactly which person or thing we are talking about. Without it, the sentence wouldn't make sense or would be too vague.

No, never use commas with defining relative clauses. Commas are only for non-defining clauses which provide extra, non-essential information.

Yes, you can. While who is more common in writing, that is used very frequently in spoken English for people.

You can leave it out if it is the object of the clause. For example, in 'The man (who) I saw,' you can remove who because 'I' is the subject.

We use who for people and which for things or animals. Using which for a person sounds very strange to native speakers!

No, this is a common mistake. Instead of saying 'The thing what I want,' you should say 'The thing that I want.'

Use whose to replace possessive adjectives like 'his,' 'her,' or 'their.' For example: 'The boy whose bike was stolen.'

Actually, no! You can use whose for things too, like 'The company whose logo is blue.'

Use where for places. 'This is the park where I run.' You don't need a preposition like 'in' when you use where.

Yes, but you usually need a preposition. 'This is the park which I run in' or 'in which I run.'

It is very rare and formal. Most people just use who or leave it out entirely in conversation.

The sentence will usually feel incomplete or the meaning will change. 'The cars are fast' is different from 'The cars that have turbo engines are fast.'

Because it 'defines' or limits the noun. It picks one specific noun out of a larger group.

No, that is only used in defining clauses. For non-defining clauses (with commas), you must use who or which.

In American English, that is much more common for defining clauses involving things. In British English, both are used.

Yes, it must come immediately after the noun it describes to avoid confusion. 'The dog that is barking' not 'The dog is barking that is brown.'

Yes! For example: 'I am looking for the keys that I lost.' The clause defines 'keys' at the end.

If there is another noun or pronoun (like I, you, the dog) immediately after the relative pronoun, it is likely the object.

Many languages use a similar structure, but English is unique in how it allows you to drop the pronoun entirely.

Yes! If you consider a pet part of the family, using who is very common and sweet.

Try describing objects around you using that. 'The coffee that is on my desk is cold.' It builds muscle memory!

هل كان هذا مفيداً؟
لا توجد تعليقات بعد. كن أول من يشارك أفكاره!

ابدأ تعلم اللغات مجاناً

ابدأ التعلم مجاناً