Passé Composé vs Imparfait - Action vs Description
Use Imparfait to set the scene and Passé Composé to trigger the action in your story.
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Passé Composé is for specific, completed actions and 'what happened' next.
- Imparfait is for background descriptions, habits, and 'how things were'.
- Use Passé Composé for sudden changes or events that interrupt the background.
- Use Imparfait for weather, time, age, feelings, and repeated past actions.
Quick Reference
| Feature | Passé Composé | Imparfait |
|---|---|---|
| Main Function | Completed Actions | Ongoing States / Habits |
| Visual Analogy | A snapshot / flash | A video / background |
| Typical Keywords | Soudain, Hier, Une fois | Souvent, Toujours, D'habitude |
| English Equivalent | I did / I have done | I was doing / I used to do |
| Story Role | The Plot | The Setting |
| Formation | Auxiliary + Past Participle | Nous-stem + endings |
主な例文
3 / 8Hier, j'ai acheté un nouveau vélo.
Yesterday, I bought a new bike.
Quand j'étais petit, j'aimais le chocolat.
When I was little, I liked chocolate.
Je regardais la télé quand le téléphone a sonné.
I was watching TV when the phone rang.
The 'Was -ing' Rule
If you can translate a sentence as 'was doing' or 'were doing' in English, it is almost certainly the imparfait in French.
Don't Overthink 'Duration'
An action can last 10 years, but if you specify the start and end (e.g., 'from 1990 to 2000'), you must use the passé composé!
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Passé Composé is for specific, completed actions and 'what happened' next.
- Imparfait is for background descriptions, habits, and 'how things were'.
- Use Passé Composé for sudden changes or events that interrupt the background.
- Use Imparfait for weather, time, age, feelings, and repeated past actions.
Overview
Imagine you are a movie director. You have two different cameras to film the past. One camera captures the fast-paced action scenes. The other camera captures the beautiful, slow-motion background scenery. In French, these two cameras are the passé composé and the imparfait. If you want to tell a great story, you need both. Using only one is like watching a movie with no actors or a movie with no set. You use the passé composé for the big events that move the plot forward. You use the imparfait to set the mood and describe the world. Mastering the dance between these two is the secret to sounding truly fluent. It is the difference between saying "I went to Paris" and "I was in Paris, the sun was shining, and then I saw a cat."
How This Grammar Works
Think of the passé composé as a camera flash. It captures a specific, finished moment in time. It has a clear beginning and a clear end. On the other hand, the imparfait is like a long, continuous video. It shows things that were already happening or things that happened over and over again. When you speak, you are constantly switching between these two perspectives. You use the imparfait to describe the "status quo" or the background. Then, you use the passé composé to interrupt that background with a specific action. It is like a grammar traffic light. The imparfait is the green light where things are flowing. The passé composé is the red light that marks a specific stop or change. Yes, even native speakers pause for a microsecond to choose the right one, so don't worry if you do too!
Formation Pattern
- 1For the
passé composé, you need two parts: a helping verb (avoirorêtre) and a past participle. - 2Most verbs use
avoir. For example,j'ai mangé(I ate). - 3A small group of movement verbs (the Dr. Mrs. Vandertramp list) and reflexive verbs use
être. For example,je suis allé(I went). - 4For the
imparfait, take thenousform of the present tense, drop the-ons, and add the endings:-ais,-ais,-ait,-ions,-iez,-aient. - 5For example,
parlerbecomesnous parlons. Drop-onsto getparl-. Then add the ending:je parlais(I was speaking). - 6The only truly irregular verb in the
imparfaitisêtre, which uses the stemét-(e.g.,j'étais).
When To Use It
Use the passé composé when you can point to a specific spot on a calendar or a clock. It is for actions that are completed. If you can say "and then..." after the sentence, it is probably passé composé. Use it for a sequence of events: "I woke up, I drank coffee, and I left." Each of those is a finished action. Use it for a change in state: "Suddenly, I became sad."
Use the imparfait for descriptions. This includes the weather (il faisait beau), time (il était midi), age (j'avais dix ans), and physical or mental states (j'étais fatigué). It is also the tense for habits. If you did something regularly in the past, like "I used to play soccer every Sunday," use the imparfait (je jouais au foot). It is the "used to" or "was doing" tense.
When Not To Use It
Do not use the passé composé for background information that doesn't have a specific end. If you say j'ai été fatigué, it sounds like you were tired for one specific second and then it was over. Usually, you want j'étais fatigué because tiredness is a state of being.
Do not use the imparfait for the main "interrupting" action. If you are telling a story about a car crash, the crash itself is not imparfait. The crash is a sudden, plot-changing event. If you use imparfait for the crash, it sounds like the car was eternally crashing in a weird time loop. Nobody wants that.
Common Mistakes
One big mistake is using être as a helping verb for everything. Remember, j'ai été means "I was/have been" (completed), while j'étais means "I was" (ongoing description). Another classic is forgetting that soudain (suddenly) almost always triggers the passé composé. If something happens suddenly, it is an action, not a description. Also, watch out for the verb penser. If you say j'ai pensé, it means "The thought crossed my mind once." If you say je pensais, it means "I was thinking" or "I used to think." It is a subtle difference, but it changes the whole vibe of your sentence.
Contrast With Similar Patterns
In English, we often just use the Simple Past ("I ate") for everything. This makes French feel tricky. Think of it this way: imparfait is like the scenery in a play (the trees, the house, the lighting). The passé composé is the actors walking onto the stage and saying their lines. If you are describing a job interview, the fact that you were nervous is imparfait (j'étais nerveux). The moment you shook the manager's hand is passé composé (j'ai serré la main). If you are ordering food and describing a past meal, the taste was imparfait (c'était délicieux), but the act of ordering was passé composé (j'ai commandé).
Quick FAQ
Q. Can I use both in the same sentence?
A. Absolutely! "I was sleeping (imparfait) when the phone rang (passé composé)."
Q. How do I know which one to use for "was"?
A. If "was" describes a state or background, use imparfait. If it describes a completed event, use passé composé.
Q. Are there trigger words?
A. Yes! Souvent (often) usually goes with imparfait. Hier (yesterday) or tout à coup (suddenly) usually go with passé composé.
Q. Is one more common than the other?
A. They are equally important. You can't tell a story without both. It's like asking if the left or right leg is more important for walking.
Reference Table
| Feature | Passé Composé | Imparfait |
|---|---|---|
| Main Function | Completed Actions | Ongoing States / Habits |
| Visual Analogy | A snapshot / flash | A video / background |
| Typical Keywords | Soudain, Hier, Une fois | Souvent, Toujours, D'habitude |
| English Equivalent | I did / I have done | I was doing / I used to do |
| Story Role | The Plot | The Setting |
| Formation | Auxiliary + Past Participle | Nous-stem + endings |
The 'Was -ing' Rule
If you can translate a sentence as 'was doing' or 'were doing' in English, it is almost certainly the imparfait in French.
Don't Overthink 'Duration'
An action can last 10 years, but if you specify the start and end (e.g., 'from 1990 to 2000'), you must use the passé composé!
The Storyteller's Secret
Use the imparfait for all your 'setting the scene' details (weather, clothes, feelings) to make your stories more vivid.
Native Speed
In casual speech, the 'ne' in 'je n'ai pas' often disappears, but the distinction between 'ai' and 'avais' remains crucial for meaning.
例文
8Hier, j'ai acheté un nouveau vélo.
Focus: j'ai acheté
Yesterday, I bought a new bike.
A specific, completed action in the past.
Quand j'étais petit, j'aimais le chocolat.
Focus: j'étais
When I was little, I liked chocolate.
A state of being and a general preference in the past.
Je regardais la télé quand le téléphone a sonné.
Focus: a sonné
I was watching TV when the phone rang.
Imparfait sets the scene; Passé Composé interrupts it.
Tous les samedis, nous allions au marché.
Focus: allions
Every Saturday, we used to go to the market.
A repeated action/habit uses the imparfait.
✗ J'ai été faim. → ✓ J'avais faim.
Focus: J'avais
I was hungry.
Hunger is a physical state, so we use the imparfait.
✗ Soudain, il pleuvait. → ✓ Soudain, il a plu.
Focus: a plu
Suddenly, it started raining.
'Soudain' indicates a change in action, requiring passé composé.
L'entreprise a réalisé un profit record l'année dernière.
Focus: a réalisé
The company made a record profit last year.
A specific business achievement is a completed action.
Il a plu pendant trois heures.
Focus: a plu
It rained for three hours.
Even if it lasted long, the specific duration makes it passé composé.
自分をテスト
Choose the correct tense for the background description.
Pendant que je ___ (dormir), mon chat a mangé mon petit-déjeuner.
The act of sleeping is the background state during which the action (eating) happened.
Choose the correct tense for a sudden event.
Tout à coup, elle ___ (décider) de partir.
'Tout à coup' (all of a sudden) triggers the passé composé because it marks a specific moment.
Choose the correct tense for a childhood habit.
Quand nous ___ (être) jeunes, nous jouions souvent ici.
Being young is a continuous state in the past, requiring the imparfait.
🎉 スコア: /3
ビジュアル学習ツール
Action vs. Background
Which Tense Should I Use?
Is it a specific, completed action?
Does it have a clear start and end?
Is it part of a sequence of events?
Common Trigger Words
Passé Composé
- • Soudain
- • Puis
- • Une fois
- • Hier
Imparfait
- • Souvent
- • Toujours
- • D'habitude
- • Pendant que
よくある質問
20 問The passé composé is for specific actions that happened and finished. The imparfait is for descriptions and habits that were ongoing.
It depends! Use j'étais for descriptions (I was tall) and j'ai été for specific events (I was surprised by the news).
Usually the imparfait. For example, il faisait beau (the weather was nice) sets the scene for your story.
Yes, very often! Example: Je lisais (Imp) quand il est entré (PC). One action was happening when another interrupted it.
The endings are -ais, -ais, -ait, -ions, -iez, and -aient. They are added to the present tense nous stem.
Almost always. Soudain (suddenly) indicates a sudden change or action, which is the specialty of the passé composé.
Use j'avais for 'I had' as a state (I had a dog). Use j'ai eu for 'I got' or 'I had' as a specific event (I had an accident).
Yes! If you did something every day or every summer, use the imparfait. Example: Nous mangions des glaces chaque été.
If you can clearly see the end of the action in your mind, or if it's a single event in a sequence, it's completed.
It's the only one! Its stem is ét- because the nous form sommes doesn't end in -ons, so the rule doesn't work.
Yes, if the time is defined. J'ai habité à Paris pendant dix ans uses PC because the ten years are a finished block.
The imparfait. Example: Elle avait les yeux bleus (She had blue eyes). This is a descriptive state.
Usually the imparfait. Example: Je pensais que... (I thought that...) or Il était triste (He was sad).
Always use the imparfait. Je jouais means 'I was playing' or 'I used to play'.
It usually triggers the imparfait because it introduces an ongoing action (While I was...). Pendant que je cuisinais...
People will still understand you, but the 'timing' of your story might feel a bit weird or robotic to a native speaker.
No. J'ai fait is 'I did' (once). Je faisais is 'I was doing' or 'I used to do' (repeatedly/ongoing).
Neither. They are both used in both formal and informal French. You need both for basic communication.
Yes. Il était huit heures (It was eight o'clock) is a descriptive background fact.
Try writing a short story. Use the imparfait for the first two sentences to set the scene, then passé composé for the action.
関連する文法
Passé Composé with Avoir - Formation
Overview Imagine you are sitting at a café in Paris. You want to tell your friend about your day. You bought a croissan...
Passé Composé with Être - DR MRS VANDERTRAMP
Overview Welcome to the world of the French past tense. Most verbs use `avoir` as their helper. However, a small, elite...
Past Participle Agreement with Être
Overview Imagine your verb is a mirror. It reflects the person doing the action. In English, we say "he went" and "she...
Imparfait - Formation
Overview Think of the `imparfait` as the cinematic background of your life. It is the "once upon a time" tense. You use...
Passé Composé vs Imparfait - Specific vs Habitual
Overview Welcome to the most famous duo in French grammar. Think of the `passé composé` and the `imparfait` as the two...
コメント (0)
ログインしてコメント無料で言語学習を始めよう
無料で始める