The validity of this claim
Argumentation and critical discussion expression
Use this phrase to professionally challenge or examine the truth of a statement using evidence and logic.
Em 15 segundos
- A way to check if a statement is true and logical.
- Commonly used in debates, academic writing, and professional meetings.
- Helps you sound objective and intellectually rigorous.
Significado
This phrase refers to whether a specific statement or idea is actually true, logical, or supported by evidence. It is like asking if a claim has the legal or factual right to be taken seriously.
Exemplos-chave
3 de 6In a business meeting
We need to investigate the validity of this claim before we invest.
We need to investigate the validity of this claim before we invest.
Discussing a news story with a friend
I'm not sure about the validity of this claim in the headline.
I'm not sure about the validity of this claim in the headline.
A formal academic essay
The validity of this claim is supported by several peer-reviewed studies.
The validity of this claim is supported by several peer-reviewed studies.
Contexto cultural
This expression is rooted in the Enlightenment tradition of rationalism and the scientific method, where every assertion must be tested. In modern Western culture, it is frequently used in media literacy discussions to encourage people to verify sources. It reflects a societal shift toward skepticism in the digital age.
The 'Hold Water' Trick
If you want to sound more idiomatic in casual settings, say 'That claim doesn't hold water.' It means the same thing but is less stiff!
Don't Overuse It
Using this phrase too often in one conversation can make you sound like you're trying too hard to be an intellectual.
Em 15 segundos
- A way to check if a statement is true and logical.
- Commonly used in debates, academic writing, and professional meetings.
- Helps you sound objective and intellectually rigorous.
What It Means
Think of the validity of this claim as a quality check for ideas. When you use this phrase, you are looking at a statement and asking: 'Does this hold water?' It is about checking if something is based on facts or just hot air. It is the difference between a proven theory and a wild guess.
How To Use It
You usually place this phrase at the start or end of a sentence to weigh an argument. You can say you are 'questioning,' 'evaluating,' or 'doubting' it. It sounds very smart and deliberate. Use it when you want to sound like a detective or a judge. It moves the conversation from feelings to facts.
When To Use It
Use it in a meeting when a colleague makes a bold promise. Use it when reading a news article that seems a bit fishy. It is perfect for academic writing or serious debates. You can even use it with friends if you are playfully arguing about something trivial. For example, 'I highly doubt the validity of your claim that pineapple belongs on pizza.'
When NOT To Use It
Avoid this phrase in very emotional or intimate moments. If your partner says they love you, do not ask about the validity of this claim. That is a one-way ticket to the doghouse! Also, skip it in very casual slang-heavy chats. It might make you sound a bit like a robot or a textbook.
Cultural Background
English speakers, especially in the UK and US, value 'critical thinking.' This phrase comes from legal and scientific traditions where everything must be proven. It reflects a culture that likes to debate and verify information. It became more popular as people started fighting 'fake news' and misinformation online.
Common Variations
You might hear people say 'the truth of the matter' or 'is that actually valid?' Sometimes people just say 'Does that check out?' if they want to be less formal. In legal circles, they might say 'the merits of the case.' But the validity of this claim remains the gold standard for sounding objective.
Notas de uso
This is a C2-level academic and professional expression. It sits firmly in the formal register but can be used ironically in casual speech to sound 'mock-serious.'
The 'Hold Water' Trick
If you want to sound more idiomatic in casual settings, say 'That claim doesn't hold water.' It means the same thing but is less stiff!
Don't Overuse It
Using this phrase too often in one conversation can make you sound like you're trying too hard to be an intellectual.
The Polite Challenge
In British English, saying 'I question the validity of this claim' is a very polite, 'civilized' way of calling someone a liar without using the word 'liar'.
Exemplos
6We need to investigate the validity of this claim before we invest.
We need to investigate the validity of this claim before we invest.
Used here to show professional caution regarding a proposal.
I'm not sure about the validity of this claim in the headline.
I'm not sure about the validity of this claim in the headline.
Expressing skepticism about information found online.
The validity of this claim is supported by several peer-reviewed studies.
The validity of this claim is supported by several peer-reviewed studies.
Used to provide evidence for a thesis statement.
I seriously question the validity of your claim that this is the best movie ever!
I seriously question the validity of your claim that this is the best movie ever!
Using formal language for a humorous, exaggerated effect.
Mom said you're moving? I'm checking the validity of this claim lol.
Mom said you're moving? I'm checking the validity of this claim lol.
Mixing formal phrasing with 'lol' for a lighthearted tone.
I cannot accept the validity of your claim when you have no proof.
I cannot accept the validity of your claim when you have no proof.
Setting a firm boundary in a heated discussion.
Teste-se
Choose the best word to complete the professional sentence.
The legal team is currently reviewing the ___ of this claim.
The noun 'validity' is the standard term used to describe the state of being logically or factually sound.
Which verb most naturally precedes the phrase in a skeptical context?
Many scientists ___ the validity of this claim due to lack of data.
To 'question the validity' is a very common colocation when expressing doubt.
🎉 Pontuação: /2
Recursos visuais
Formality Spectrum
Is that for real?
Talking to a best friend.
Is that true?
Asking a coworker a quick question.
The validity of this claim...
Writing a report or in a debate.
Where to use 'The validity of this claim'
Courtroom
A lawyer challenging a witness.
Science Lab
Reviewing a new discovery.
Boardroom
Analyzing market research.
University
Writing a philosophy paper.
Perguntas frequentes
10 perguntasIt means the quality of being logically or factually sound. For example, if you say the validity of this claim, you are asking if the statement is actually true.
Not at all! While it sounds legal, you can use it in any situation where you are discussing facts, like in a business meeting or an academic essay.
Yes, but it might sound a bit sarcastic or very serious. If you use it while joking, like I doubt the validity of your claim that you can eat ten tacos, it adds a funny, formal touch.
'Truth' is simply whether it happened, while validity often refers to whether the argument makes sense and is supported by evidence.
You can use it normally, but maybe add an emoji so you don't sound too cold. For example: Checking the validity of this claim... 🧐.
Technically yes, but validity is much more common and sounds more natural to native speakers.
Common verbs include question, verify, assess, challenge, and establish. For example, We need to verify the validity of this claim.
Not necessarily. It just means you are checking it. However, if you say you question the validity, it usually suggests you think it might be wrong.
Yes! It shows you have a critical mind. You could say, I always look for the validity of the claims made in data reports.
A common mistake is saying the validity of this truth. Since 'truth' is already true, you should stick to the validity of this claim or statement.
Frases relacionadas
Hold water
To be valid, logical, or true.
Fact-check
To verify the factual accuracy of a report or statement.
Substantiate an allegation
To provide evidence to prove a claim.
Take it with a grain of salt
To view a statement with skepticism.
Comentários (0)
Faça Login para ComentarComece a aprender idiomas gratuitamente
Comece Grátis