Marking Information Sources and Evidential
Evidential markers tell your listener the source and reliability of your information, making your Hindi nuanced and authentic.
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Use presumptive `होगा` for logical guesses about the present or past.
- Use `सुना है` or `कहते हैं` to mark information as hearsay.
- Use `लगता है` for sensory evidence or intuitive impressions.
- Avoid evidential markers for direct, visual facts happening right now.
Quick Reference
| Marker | Source of Info | Hindi Example | English Nuance |
|---|---|---|---|
| होगा (Presumptive) | Logic / Inference | वह पढ़ रहा होगा | He must be studying (I assume). |
| सुना है कि (Hearsay) | Second-hand report | सुना है कि छुट्टी है | I heard it's a holiday. |
| लगता है (Sensory) | Appearance / Feeling | लगता है वह नाराज़ है | It seems he is angry. |
| पता चला है (Discovery) | Newly found fact | पता चला है कि वह चोर है | It's been found out he's a thief. |
| कहते हैं (General) | Common knowledge | यहाँ भूत रहते हैं | They say ghosts live here. |
| देखा गया है (Observed) | Empirical evidence | ऐसा अक्सर देखा गया है | This has often been observed. |
主な例文
3 / 8बाज़ार में बहुत भीड़ होगी।
The market must be very crowded.
सुना है कि आपकी लॉटरी लग गई है!
I heard that you won the lottery!
लगता है आज बारिश होगी।
It seems like it will rain today.
The 90% Rule
Use `होगा` when you are about 90% sure. If you are only 50% sure, add `शायद` at the beginning of the sentence.
Future Confusion
Don't confuse `होगा` (must be) with the actual future. Context is key! 'वह कल आएगा' is future; 'वह घर पर होगा' is present inference.
The Rule in 30 Seconds
- Use presumptive `होगा` for logical guesses about the present or past.
- Use `सुना है` or `कहते हैं` to mark information as hearsay.
- Use `लगता है` for sensory evidence or intuitive impressions.
- Avoid evidential markers for direct, visual facts happening right now.
Overview
Ever wondered how to say "I heard" without sounding like a robot? In Hindi, how you know something is just as important as what you know. This is called evidentiality. It is like adding a digital watermark to your sentences. You are telling your listener if you saw it, heard it, or just guessed it. At the C1 level, you move beyond simple facts. You start using markers to show the source of your information. This makes your Hindi sound nuanced and natural. It helps you avoid sounding too bossy or too certain when you are not. Think of it as the difference between "It is raining" and "It sounds like it is raining."
How This Grammar Works
Hindi uses specific verb moods and particles to mark evidence. You do not just use one word for everything. You choose a marker based on your source. If you saw the action, you use the direct indicative. If you are guessing based on logic, you use the presumptive mood. If someone told you the news, you use reported speech markers. You can also use sensory verbs like लगना (to feel/seem). These markers act like a filter for your information. They tell the listener how much they should trust your statement. It is a subtle dance of words that locals use every day.
Formation Pattern
- 1There are four main ways to mark your sources in Hindi:
- 2Presumptive Mood (Logic/Inference):
- 3Take the verb root +
ता/ते/ती+होगा/होगी/होंगे. Example:वह आता होगा(He must be coming). - 4Reported Speech (Hearsay):
- 5Use
सुना है कि(I have heard that) orकहते हैं कि(They say that) before the main clause. - 6Sensory Evidence (Appearance):
- 7Use
लगता है कि(It seems that) orमालूम पड़ता है(It appears). - 8Discovery (New Knowledge):
- 9Use
पता चला है कि(It has come to light that) when you just found out something.
When To Use It
Use these markers when you want to be precise about your knowledge. Use the presumptive होगा when you are 90% sure but did not see it. It is perfect for guessing why a friend is late to dinner. Use सुना है when you are sharing office gossip or news from the TV. It protects you if the information is wrong! Use लगता है when the clouds look gray and you think it might rain. In a job interview, use पता चला है to show you did your research about the company. It sounds much more professional than just saying "I know."
When Not To Use It
Do not use these markers for things you are looking at right now. If you see a blue car, do not say वह नीली कार होगी. That sounds like you are blindfolded and guessing! Avoid using hearsay markers for personal feelings. You would not say "I heard that I am hungry." That is just weird. Also, do not over-stack them. Using शायद (maybe) and होगा (must be) together is often redundant. It is like wearing two hats at the same time. Pick one and stick with it for clarity.
Common Mistakes
A big mistake is using the future tense होगा only for the future. In this context, it marks a present guess. If you say वह सो रहा होगा, you mean he is sleeping right now. Another trap is forgetting the कि after सुना है. Without it, the sentence falls apart like a bad samosa. Many people also confuse लगता है (it seems) with चाहता हूँ (I want). Make sure you are describing the situation, not your desires. Yes, even native speakers get lazy with these, but as a C1 learner, you should be sharp.
Contrast With Similar Patterns
Let us compare है vs होगा vs शायद. वह घर पर है is a cold, hard fact. You are 100% sure. वह घर पर होगा is a logical guess. You know he usually stays home at this hour. शायद वह घर पर है is more about doubt. It is a 50/50 coin toss. While होगा focuses on your inference, सुना है shifts the responsibility to someone else. It is the ultimate "don't blame me if I'm wrong" card. Using लगता है is more about your personal intuition or physical senses.
Quick FAQ
Q. Does होगा always mean "must"?
A. Not always, but in this grammar, it shows a strong logical inference.
Q. Can I use पता चला for secrets?
A. Yes, it is the perfect way to start a sentence about a secret you discovered.
Q. Is कहते हैं formal?
A. It is neutral. You can use it with friends or in a speech.
Q. Why not just use शायद for everything?
A. Because शायद is vague. These markers show exactly how you got your info.
Reference Table
| Marker | Source of Info | Hindi Example | English Nuance |
|---|---|---|---|
| होगा (Presumptive) | Logic / Inference | वह पढ़ रहा होगा | He must be studying (I assume). |
| सुना है कि (Hearsay) | Second-hand report | सुना है कि छुट्टी है | I heard it's a holiday. |
| लगता है (Sensory) | Appearance / Feeling | लगता है वह नाराज़ है | It seems he is angry. |
| पता चला है (Discovery) | Newly found fact | पता चला है कि वह चोर है | It's been found out he's a thief. |
| कहते हैं (General) | Common knowledge | यहाँ भूत रहते हैं | They say ghosts live here. |
| देखा गया है (Observed) | Empirical evidence | ऐसा अक्सर देखा गया है | This has often been observed. |
The 90% Rule
Use `होगा` when you are about 90% sure. If you are only 50% sure, add `शायद` at the beginning of the sentence.
Future Confusion
Don't confuse `होगा` (must be) with the actual future. Context is key! 'वह कल आएगा' is future; 'वह घर पर होगा' is present inference.
Polite Softening
In Hindi culture, being too direct can sometimes seem rude. Using `लगता है` softens your opinion and makes you sound more humble.
The Gossip Starter
Start your sentences with `सुना है कि...` to instantly signal that you are sharing interesting news you heard elsewhere.
例文
8बाज़ार में बहुत भीड़ होगी।
Focus: होगी
The market must be very crowded.
Using the presumptive to guess based on it being a weekend.
सुना है कि आपकी लॉटरी लग गई है!
Focus: सुना है कि
I heard that you won the lottery!
Reporting something heard from others.
लगता है आज बारिश होगी।
Focus: लगता है
It seems like it will rain today.
Based on looking at the dark clouds.
उसने खाना खा लिया होगा।
Focus: लिया होगा
He must have eaten already.
Using the presumptive for a completed action.
जांच से पता चला है कि मशीन खराब थी।
Focus: पता चला है
The investigation revealed that the machine was faulty.
Formal use in a professional context.
✗ शायद वह आता होगा। → ✓ वह आता होगा।
Focus: आता होगा
He must be coming.
Don't double up 'perhaps' and 'must be' unless you want to sound very unsure.
✗ मैंने सुना कि वह बीमार है। → ✓ सुना है कि वह बीमार है।
Focus: सुना है कि
I've heard that he is sick.
The perfective 'सुना है' is more natural for current rumors.
कहने को तो वह अमीर है, पर दिखता नहीं।
Focus: कहने को तो
Reportedly he is rich, but it doesn't show.
Using 'कहने को तो' to express skepticism about the source.
自分をテスト
Choose the correct marker for a logical guess about someone's current location.
वह इस वक्त दफ़्तर में ___।
Since you are guessing 'at this time' (इस वक्त), the presumptive 'होगा' is the best fit.
Which phrase correctly introduces a rumor you heard?
___ कि कंपनी बंद हो रही है।
'सुना है' is used for hearsay or rumors.
Select the best sensory marker for a physical observation.
तुम्हारी बातों से ___ कि तुम थके हुए हो।
'लगता है' reflects an impression based on sensory input (hearing their voice).
🎉 スコア: /3
ビジュアル学習ツール
Certainty vs. Evidence
Choosing Your Marker
Did you see it yourself?
Is it a logical guess?
Did someone tell you?
Evidential Categories
Visual/Direct
- • Indicative Mood
- • Direct Sight
Auditory/Reported
- • सुना है
- • कहते हैं
Logical/Mental
- • होगा
- • शायद
New Discovery
- • पता चला
- • मालूम हुआ
よくある質問
20 問It's a grammar feature that shows the source of your information. In Hindi, we use markers like होगा or सुना है to show if we guessed it or heard it.
Not always, but when used as an evidential marker, it refers to the present or past. For example, वह सो रहा होगा means 'He must be sleeping now'.
You can use ऐसा सुनने में आया है कि... which translates to 'It has come to my hearing that...'. It sounds very sophisticated.
Yes, like मुझे ठंड लग रही है (I feel cold). But as an evidential, it means 'It seems like', as in लगता है वह बीमार है.
होगा is a logical conclusion based on patterns. शायद is just a possibility without necessarily having a strong reason.
You can say पढ़ा है कि... (I have read that...) or अख़बार के मुताबिक़ (According to the newspaper).
Not necessarily. It just means it's a common saying or rumor. It's like saying 'They say...' in English.
Yes! उसने कहा होगा means 'He must have said it'. You just use the perfective form of the main verb.
Yes, but मालूम होता है is slightly more formal and often used in literature or news.
Then you don't need an evidential marker! Just use the direct indicative: वह यहाँ है (He is here).
It can be used dismissively. होगा कोई (Must be someone/Whoever) shows you don't care who the person is.
No, it's for any new information. मुझे आज पता चला कि आज सोमवार है (I found out today that it's Monday).
No, for that use मैंने गाना सुना. सुना है is specifically for information or facts.
You can use ज़ाहिर तौर पर or simply use the होगा construction to imply it.
No, but without it, you sound very blunt. It's the difference between a textbook and a real person.
Translating 'must' as ज़रूर. While ज़रूर works, the होगा ending is much more natural for logical 'must'.
Yes, it's very common in academic or formal Hindi to mean 'It has been observed'.
Rarely. You usually know what you are doing. You'd only use it if you lost your memory or are joking!
Use मुझे शक है कि... or मुझे अंदेशा है कि... for a more formal tone.
Yes, बोलते हैं is more colloquial and common in North India for 'People say'.
関連する文法
Dative Subjects and Object Agreement
Overview Ever felt like you aren't the boss of your own feelings? In Hindi, grammar actually agrees with you. When you...
Irregular Past Tense
Overview Welcome to the world of Hindi rebels! Most Hindi verbs follow a very predictable pattern in the past tense. Yo...
Polite Imperatives
Overview Welcome to the world of Hindi politeness! Hindi is a language that values respect deeply. It uses different ve...
Irregular Future Forms of the
Overview Welcome to the future! Well, the Hindi future tense, at least. Most verbs in Hindi are very polite and follow...
Hindi Compound Verbs: Adding Nu
Overview Welcome to the world of Hindi compound verbs! If you want to sound like a native, you need to master the art o...
コメント (0)
ログインしてコメント無料で言語学習を始めよう
無料で始める